08/01/2026
I have seen a lot mixed comments and recieved questions to do with the new US dietary guidelines, so I have decided to do a brief(ish) post now, more later.
Note: the "old pyramid" has been out of use for about 15yrs in the US and Aust - so comparing against them and ignoring the ones each country has had in the mean time is also an issue
Points being raised include:
Grains no longer the base -> they are a COMPONENT not the base
Protein prioritised -> it has never not been a key component priority
Strong push towards whole foods -> they are always have been
Reduce Processed foods -> again has been recommended to limit/reduce intake for years
Added sugar discouraged -> as above
Healthy fats re-introduced -> healthy fats have always been encouraged...the issue is what's considered healthy and the quantities
Instead of counting calories focus more on food quality - not sure about the old US the guidelines but in the ADGs, there's a guide of each food group on what kJ/calories are in one serve, but not a focus on them, and there are a large and growing component of the profession who have been pushing and emphasising this practice for years
Gut health and fermented foods -> they aren't in the current guidelines per say (in Aust), because it's a relatively new area of research and extremely complex, but dietitians ARE emphasising those
Each person is an individual - again we have been saying this for years and fighting for that to be recognised
The old ones don't work - most people weren't following them so blaming the guidelines for "poor health" is not a fair assessment.
Old guidelines are industry driven - ignoring blatent conflicts of the meat and dairy industries (and possibly others) is extremely hypocritical.
On the surface they look great - prioritising whole foods is always going to be great, but as with most things deeper dives are needed to know the whether they are as great as people think they are/want them to be. Most important thing is to listen to the trained/qualified professionals more than "Joe Blow" on the internet for your health and nutrition advice.