25/11/2025
Rating Diets Out of 10 - as I mentioned in the last post, nutrition very rarely comes without caveats or nuances so a simple rating is a very basic way to communicate views without education, read below for a bit more reasoning into why each diet gets its rating:
🥩 Carnivore – 1/10. Extreme and restrictive. You’ll miss out on fibre, vitamins, and minerals found in plants. Studies show an increase risk of dyslipideamia and colon cancer. Not ideal for long-term health.
🥓 Low Carb – 2/10. Can work short-term for weight loss, but cutting major food groups long-term can lead to deficiencies and low energy. Carbs are the brains first source of energy, don’t deny your brain its primary food.
💪 High Protein, High Fibre – 10/10. Wins every time. Supports muscle, gut health, satiety, and long-term wellbeing.
🥤 Protein Powder – 10/10. Shouldn’t completely replace getting protein from whole foods, but it’s a super convenient way to meet protein needs.
🌱 Vegan – 7/10 (if done well). Can be healthy, but needs planning for protein, iron, B12, calories, and other nutrients.
🥗 Plant-Based (predominantly plants + lean meat/fish) – 10/10. Balanced, nutrient-dense, sustainable. Covers all bases without extremes.
🚫 Cutting Out Seed Oils – 5/10. Individually, seeds oils are not the devil people make them out to be, though often they’re in highly processed foods so if you aim to cut them out, you often cut out a bunch of high calorie, high fat foods. Hence the 5/10. Seed oils aren’t the enemy, but they come in a package deal with unhealthy foods.
⏱️ Intermittent Fasting – 4/10. Can work for some, but risk of muscle loss if protein and calories aren’t adequate.
🍽️ 80/20 Approach – 10/10. Consistency over perfection. Eat well 80% of the time, enjoy treats 20%. Helps you stick to healthy habits long-term.
📊 Tracking Macros – 8-10. Great for accountability and learning about your body. Not a diet itself, but an education tool.
🥤 Juice Cleanse – 0/10. Not sustainable, high sugar, now fibre or protein, can mess with blood sugar. Skip it.
There’s no one-size-fits-all, but focus on balanced, nutrient-rich, sustainable eating and leave the extremes behind.