14/10/2024
Great article
The Problems of Being Human 💋
This is a photo of me hugging a horse, and in the horse’s typical gentle, stoic way, this mare is tolerating it but definitely not enjoying it. The only thing that probably would have made her more zoned out is if I kissed her!
I used to be completely oblivious to the fact that horses don’t really enjoy my socially and culturally hardwired desire to hug and kiss them. Even to this day, I have to consciously control my urge to show my enthusiasm and affection to a horse by hugging and kissing them.
I was unaware of this until a rainy day about a decade ago when I was laying on my bed reading dog trainer Dr Patricia McConnell’s book "On the Other End of the Leash". It’s a book about how our human tendencies can get in the way of our relationships with dogs. McConnell points out that we are primates and dogs are canines, and our two species perceive the world and interactions very differently. We tend to anthropomorphise our interpretations of other animals, including dogs and horses. Anthropomorphism is the attribution of human traits, emotions, or intentions to animals. It means we struggle to recognise that other animals do not think, act, or perceive the world as we do. A display of affection for us, can be a threat of aggression to them :/
Anyway, I was reading the book and had come to a part where McConnell explained that hugging can be confronting and uncomfortable for many dogs. To some, it can even feel threatening. She also pointed out that patting a dog on the head isn’t particularly enjoyable for them either. At that point, I got up to get a drink. My dog Callaghan was curled up on the bed near me. I did what I always did when I saw him—because he melted my heart, being such a beautiful boy—I bent down, hugged, and kissed him. It was at that moment I saw it for the first time, and it was confronting. For the first time, I noticed him cringe. He tolerated it but looked away from me, started panting, and yawned. What I had read in that book hadn’t really sunk in before, but it did then, and from that moment on, I became aware of my human urges to kiss and hug animals and began being more respectful about it.
It’s one of those things that, once you see it, you can’t unsee it. So, I’ll say now that I apologise to everyone out there who will now see it and hate me for it. I’m sure I’ll get a number of comments from people telling me they have horses, dogs, or cats that love hugs and kisses. I’m not going to argue with you, and that’s terrific, but I found a lot of peace and honour in respecting other species’ preferences for showing my love and affection. I no longer just touch, hug, or kiss unconsciously. It also stopped that feeling of rejection when a horse or dog moved away or didn't like being touched. It is amazing how understanding can help the way you feel about something ❤
I guess if I can respect that certain cultures don’t hug or kiss either and might bow or shake hands instead, then I can work out what the animals in my life like.
I’ve learnt to really appreciate a horse that allows me to stand close and remain calm and secure in my presence. I take my time finding places they may like to be scratched, but if touch really isn’t their thing, then I’m okay with that. The dog that appreciates sniffing my hand and letting me stroke them gently under the chin or ears—that was Callaghan’s favourite thing, and I was able to work that out once I stopped and paid attention. I loved seeing how much he adored that❤
When I talk about this while working with people and their horses, I’m sometimes misunderstood, as if I don’t like “loving on” a horse. Nothing could be further from the truth. That desire is strong, and I’ll admit that sometimes I still impose a hug on a horse😬, and I do love finding their favourite scratch spots. It’s just that I worked out that loving on a horse was more about me than them, and I’ve taught myself to find great meaning in just standing with them, moving with them, feeling them be okay in my presence, and following me where I guide them❤.