12/31/2025
âźDON'T READ THIS BOOKâź
Babywise is often recommended to exhausted new parents as a âsolutionâ for sleep and feeding, but the truth is uncomfortable: it is not evidence-based, and it can seriously damage a breastfeeding relationship.
1. It prioritizes schedules over biology
Newborns are not wired for rigid schedules. Their stomachs are tiny and their feeding needs change constantly. Breastfeeding works best on-demandâfeeding when the baby shows cues, not when a clock says itâs time. Babywise pushes scheduled feeds that ignore normal infant behavior and physiology.
2. It contradicts breastfeeding science
Milk supply is built through frequent, effective milk removalâespecially in the early weeks. Encouraging parents to delay feeds, stretch time between feeds, or ignore hunger cues can lead to:
Decreased milk supply
Poor infant weight gain
Increased supplementation or early weaning
These outcomes arenât âparent failureââtheyâre predictable consequences of advice that clashes with how lactation actually works.
3. It promotes harmful interpretations of newborn behavior
Crying, cluster feeding, and frequent waking are not âbad habits.â They are normal survival behaviors. Babywise frames these behaviors as problems to be corrected instead of communication to be responded to.
4. It increases stress for parents
Babywise teaches parents to distrust their instincts and ignore their baby, which raises cortisol.
5. It lacks support
Modern pediatric and lactation guidance consistently supports responsive feeding, especially for breastfed infants. Babywise stands outside this consensus, relying on anecdote and ideology rather than high-quality research.
The bottom line is that breastfeeding thrives on flexibility, responsiveness, and trustâtrust in your body and your baby. Babywise replaces that trust with rigid rules that often sabotage milk supply, infant growth, and parental confidence.
If a feeding philosophy makes breastfeeding harder, more stressful, or feel âwrong,â thatâs not a failure of you or your babyâitâs a failure of the advice.
You and your baby deserve support thatâs grounded in science, compassion, and how babies actually work.