08/06/2025
When a Child Won’t Tell the Truth—What’s Really Happening? 🤔
You’ve probably had this moment before—you're with a child, and you know they’re lying.
Maybe you saw it with your own eyes. Maybe you have undeniable proof. Maybe you just know.
And yet, they won’t admit it.
You might feel the urge to say:
💭 “Just tell me the truth!”
💭 “I saw you do it—why are you lying?”
💭 “You’re only making this worse!”
But here’s something to consider: Telling the truth isn’t just about honesty. It’s about safety.
Why Do Children Struggle to Tell the Truth?
Before a child can tell you the truth, they first have to be able to tell themselves the truth.
And that? That’s not always easy.
1️⃣ It Has to Feel Safe on the Inside
Even beyond external safety, the child has to be able to sit with the truth within themselves first.
If a child already carries feelings of:
❌ Internalized guilt
❌ Internalized shame
❌ Internalized inadequacy
…then admitting the truth means facing those feelings head-on. And for many children, that’s too much.
Lying isn’t just about avoiding consequences—it’s about avoiding feeling like a bad person.
2️⃣ It Has to Feel Safe on the Outside
A child will only tell the truth if it feels safe enough to do so.
🔹 If telling the truth means shame…
🔹 If telling the truth means anger or rejection…
🔹 If telling the truth means getting in trouble…
Then why would they admit it? Why would they put themselves in harm’s way?
If the reaction to truth-telling is fear-based, the brain registers lying as the safer option.
So What Can We Do?
Instead of demanding the truth, try creating safety first.
✔️ Regulate before you respond. If your own frustration rises, pause. Take a breath. Shift from “I need them to tell me the truth” to “What’s making it hard for them to be honest?”
✔️ Normalize that mistakes happen. “Sometimes we make choices we don’t feel good about. That doesn’t change how I see you.”
✔️ Make honesty feel like connection, not punishment. “It’s okay to tell me the truth. I’ll be here with you.”
So the next time you catch yourself wanting a child to “just tell the truth,” pause and ask:
💡 Does this child feel safe enough—inside and out—to be honest?
💡 What fears or internal struggles might be getting in the way?
💡 How can I make truth-telling a safe and supported experience?
Because when we create safety first, honesty follows.
Much love on the journey 💜
Lisa