12/12/2023
A growing phenomena In the past decade is the introduction of gadgets that claim to be able to measure functions such as energy expenditure, steps walked per day, quality and quantity of sleep etc. These devices are aggressively marketed to us and seem like they could provide useful information that would help translate to better health and wellness outcomes. For some, especially those who have cardio vascular issues, whom require ongoing monitoring, they probably do. However, risks need to be evaluated as well. The first question though, is wether they do a good job measuring what they claim they do. Meta analysis (research analyzing all the trials done trying to answer the question of wether these devices measure accurately what they claim to measure) have concluded that these devices aren't as accurate as they claim to be. Now we can ask, even if the technology improves and becomes more accurate, are there risks to using these technologies? In my opinion (no data to back it up), I see two main issues with these technologies.
First, I predict that people using these technologies will end up exercising less than their peers without the technology (reminds me of the social media websites and apps story, initially these websites brought the promise of connecting people and communities together but in practice ended up helping create more feeling of loneliness and isolation in individuals and societies), having number of steps per day achieved and then feeling like there is no need to further move or exercise, or giving out on a workout because the gadget said you didn’t get a good nights sleep.
Second, I think there is a problem when turning to technology with questions we should know the answer to by paying attention to our body's own feedback loops. So the biggest disadvantage here is loosing the ability to connect with our body and listen to what is going on inside us, or in other words, figuring out what we are feeling inside requires practice (like emotions), using a gadget to give us the answer instead of us practicing noticing how we feel will diminish our awareness. Less awareness (physical or emotional) makes one more vulnerable to developing problems. I think each of us should be able to tell whether they got a full nights sleep and feel rested or not, wether they had enough to eat during or after a meal or wether they moved or exercised enough for the day.
I guess we will wait and see where this phenomena takes us..