05/29/2025
This cuts deep. I have seen things like this in my career, too. Thankfully, it is getting less common. When we know better, we can do better.
It's time to "do the weather", like it or not.
Better ways than ABA
I was working in a pre-school autism class: an ABA classroom. It was a new school day early in the year, and it was time for "morning meeting". However, one little girl (non-speaking) wasn't feeling it that day. She was having a tough morning.
That didn't appear to matter to the adults in the room. According to their schedule, it was time for morning meeting, period. The little girl was led to her plastic cube chair by her paraprofessional who sat behind her, coaching her and containing her.
As morning meeting continued with the attendance, the days of the week, months of the year, letter of the week, the almanac, the horoscopes and everything else they cover in these way-too-long meetings, it was time to "do the weather". That was this little girl's task. The parapofessional tried to lift her up out of her cube chair, but she resisted, dropping to the ground. As the para tried to pick her up, she resisted further. This little girl's difficult morning just got worse.
The resistance (or self-advocacy) was unacceptable to the teacher, who instructed the para to keep placing the demand on her and don't let her be "comfortable" on the floor. The para did what she was told. She stood over the little girl and rapidly repeated "do the weather" at nauseam.
Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather.
The little girl would not comply, so a large blue bin of Legos was dumped on the floor, by the adults. Now crying, the little girl was instructed to pick the Legos up, all while the para continued: Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather. Do the weather.
They were not going to "let her win". That's what they said. They were going to get her to comply.
Eventually, they broke her.
She did the weather.
Her face was red, tears running down her cheeks, but she put the sunshine cutout where it was supposed to go.
They praised her for doing the weather. "Good job!" She didn't care. She was done. It was before 10 am and this little girl was exhausted, demoralized and just done.
Years later, I can still hear that para saying "do the weather, do the weather, do the weather, do the weather". It haunts me. It traumatized that little girl who was just having a bad day. Even though we ALL have bad days, apparently you weren't allowed to have a bad day if you're a student in this classroom.
Alternative ending: Rewind to the beginning of the day. Upon seeing the child was not herself, the para could have taken her for a walk outside. You know what's outside? THE FREAKIN' WEATHER!
She could have taken some time to help the child get regulated and actually "notice" the weather while outside. The para could have calmly asked if the now regulated little girl would like to share her news about the weather with her class. I'm positive she would've participated.
I was a newer OT at the time. The shock of the inhumane treatment, coupled with the fear of speaking up, made me a spectator instead of an advocate.
We can no longer be spectators. We MUST be a voice for children.
We can do better. We need to bring the humanity back into our classrooms and re-think our behavior "management" strategies.