22/07/2021
“Don’t eat 1,200 calories a day!”
The above statement sounds very definitive doesn’t it? It’s as if going down to 1,200 calories is bad and you’ve done something wrong.
But actually the statement is incorrect and misleading. I’ve seen a few posts recently about this and I’m not sure why they’ve chosen 1,200 as the ‘devil’ number - possibly because some well known fitness influencer has probably posted something and with the fitness industry lacking originality they run with it.
Eating 1,200 calories is not bad! But whether you should do it will depend on you and your situation. The industry is too quick to go down the one approach fits all whereby something is either right or wrong. There’s no in between. Most answers I give start with “it depends”.
Take the 1,200 calories statement. Should you do it? Now there’s sooo many questions that should be asked and this is why I would sit down with a new client for 1-2 hours after they’ve filled in a detailed consultation form so that I know as much as possible before working with them to create a strategy.
To anyone who makes this statement I would challenge them and say…
What about the structure of the calorie intake? Someone that does a 5:2 fasting approach may benefit from going much lower on two days a week to allow for more calories on the other five days. If that suits their lifestyle then why not?
What about if they have to drop their calories low because of their starting point? Take a 5 ft 2 female weighing 70kg will very low activity levels. Their maintenance is likely going to be around the 1,700-1,800 mark and so If they want to drop 1lb a week then their calorie intake will have to be around 1,200-1,300 mark to achieve this.
What if someone wants to lose it quicker and they are in a great position to do so? Research has shown that for SOME people a faster rate of weight loss is more motivating and the thought of dieting harder but for a shorter period of time is more suitable.
Yes there will be people arguing “but it’s not sustainable” but a calorie deficit is only sustainable for as long as it needs to be. No one can maintain a deficit forever - if they did they’d eventually die. So whether you go fast or slow with your weight loss you’re only going to be able to sustain it until you reach your desired goal or you cannot stick to the diet protocol any longer. Now if it is the latter then it might suggest that their current approach is too much for them. But again this is where it comes down the right education and advice.
Some might say that it will give a person an eating disorder. Again, you cannot be so definitive. But if someone has a history of issues with their eating then yes, absolutely going very restrictive isn’t something I’d suggest but I’d also say if someone is struggling with their relationship with food and there’s a long history associated with this then no personal trainer is qualified to advise those people - it’s out our scope of practise. They should be seeking the help from a professional (dietician and/or psychologist).
Also, to quickly answer the “but they’ll go into starvation mode”… no, that’s not true. The other argument people use is “they’ll just regain it and more”… again, no, this is not guaranteed to happen.
I’ll finish off by saying that a lot of the time people cannot stick to 1,200 calories and often is the case that they don’t even need to go that low but I want to emphasise that with nearly all topics related to health and fitness the answer may change from one person to the next.
If you have any questions feel free to message me.