25/11/2025
šæ āPicking Your Battlesā Through a Polyvagal Lens
Yesterday I had my 2 year old Grand-daughter for the day. She is at the stage where she wants autonomy; she is developing her uniqueness and pushing boundaries. She is also recovering from tonsillitis. So when she said she wanted to keep her pyjamas on and not get dressed, I said Ok. We were only going to my house so it really didnt matter. When I mentioned this to someone later, they told me I was spoiling her and 'she had to learn.' I suggested that maybe they needed to learn all about behaviour and regulation. Stephen Porges' Poly-vagal theory has the answers.
Polyvagal Theory helps us understand that behaviour isnāt about defiance or being difficult ā itās about nervous system state.
When a child feels safe, they can learn, cooperate and connect. When they feel threatened, overwhelmed, or out of control, they shift into fight, flight, or shutdown.
Picking your battles is really about choosing interactions that keep the child in ā or gently guide them back to ā the safe and social state.
ā What āpicking your battlesā means polyvagally
1ļøā£ Protecting the childās sense of safety
Before reacting to a behaviour, we ask:
* āWill intervening increase their feeling of safety?ā
* āOr will it push them further into fight/flight/shutdown?ā
If the correction will feel like a threat to the childās nervous system, it's usually not worth the battle.
2ļøā£ Reducing unnecessary triggers
Many ābattlesā come from:
* sensory overload
* loss of predictability
* demand pressure
* social anxiety
* fatigue
* transitions
Avoiding or softening triggers means the child is less likely to dysregulate, so fewer battles arise.
3ļøā£ Prioritising connection over compliance
Polyvagal Theory teaches that connection comes before cooperation.
A connected child:
* can follow boundaries
* can co-regulate
* can learn and repair
A stressed child cannot.
So we pick battles that maintain or repair connection, not ones that damage it.
4ļøā£ Choosing moments when the child is regulated
You cannot teach when the child is in:
* fight (hitting, shouting)
* flight (running away, refusing)
* freeze/shutdown (silent, still, withdrawn)
If a battle pushes them deeper into these states, itās counterproductive.
We intervene most effectively when the child is:
* calm enough
* connected enough
* safe enough
ā What battles ARE worth picking (polyvagally)
š”ļø 1. Safety
Anything that risks serious harm requires intervention, but done with calm, predictable energy:
e.g. āIāll keep you safe. Iām going to move the scissors away.ā
š 2. Protection of othersā nervous systems
If the childās actions dysregulate others (younger sibling, pet), you step in gently but clearly:
E.g. āI canāt let you hit. My job is to keep all bodies safe.ā
š§ 3. Co-regulation learning
Moments where you can teach regulation, not punish behaviour:
E.g. āLetās pause together. Breathe with me. Your body feels fast.ā
ā What battles are not worth picking (polyvagally)
š«§ Situations where the child is dysregulated
Correcting behaviour in a meltdown or shutdown is not helpful. Their system cannot learn at that moment.
š Issues rooted in sensory need or anxiety
* needing the same cup
* refusing certain clothes
* lining up toys
* needing quiet space
These are regulation strategies, not misbehaviour.
š§© Situations where the adult goal is preference, not necessity
If the thing only matters to the adultās idea of āhow it should be,ā let it go.
š„ Any battle that increases demand pressure
Especially for PDA profiles, added demands trigger threat responses.
If the demand is not essential, reducing it prevents escalation.
ā A simple Polyvagal rule:
If your response will pull the child OUT of safety⦠donāt pick the battle
If your response will move the child:
* towards calm,
* towards connection,
* towards regulation,
then itās worth engaging.
š Examples (Polyvagal + neurodivergent)
š© Not worth the battle
* Wanting the blue cup instead of the green
* Wearing mismatched clothing/keeping PJs on
* Jumping on the sofa safely
* Avoiding eye contact
* Eating only preferred foods that day
* Needing extra time to transition
These are regulation choices or sensory needs.
š„ Worth the battle (done calmly)
* Running into the road
* Aggressive actions that could hurt someone
* Touching hot surfaces
* Throwing heavy objects
* Unsafe climbing
Because safety restores the nervous system, not threatens it.
ā The Polyvagal Flow for Adults
When a possible battle arises: As yourself DIRM (Does it really matter?)
1. Pause
Notice your nervous system. Are you regulated?
2. Assess
Is this about safety or learning? Or about preference?
3. Connect
Use warm tone, proximity, soft eyes.
4. Co-regulate
Slow your breathing. Offer a simple support (āIām right here.ā)
5. Guide
Offer the boundary calmly and predictably.
I dont think they will speak to me again but Does It Really Matter?