18/08/2021
Matthew Remski on Conspiritualists and Anti-vaxxers:
"they did not create their followers’ disillusionment with science or the state, with modernity, or the poisoned chalice of techno-capitalism. They exploited a reasonable disenchantment.
In Virtue Hoarders: the Case Against the Professional Managerial Class, media studies professor Catherine Liu offers a withering takedown of the “PMC”, which John and Barbara Ehrenreich first defined in 1977 as “salaried mental workers who do not own the means of production and whose major function in the social division of labor may be described broadly as the reproduction of capitalist culture and capitalist class relations."
The daily work of institutions, whether corporate or of the state, is performed by well-educated, privileged managers. Their main task is to keep the culture running smoothly, regardless of the direction it’s going in. They administrate and bless this ultimate phase of the American dream. They apply their education and gentility to the management of state functions without ever challenging the premises of the system: how it distributes wealth, how it works to enhance equality, how it treats children, the elderly, the sick, and the incarcerated, and how it might apply brakes to the excesses of imperialism or consumption while the world burns.
Liu proposes that MAGA-type movements are in part reactions to neoliberal management:
'Across the world, ordinary people without college degrees have rejected PMC technocracy in favor of populist authoritarianism because they no longer believe in the dominant neoliberal narrative about austerity and competition. To the majority of non-college-educated people, the PMC increasingly appear as pedantic, hypocritical, and punishing: in authoritarian, science denying conservative leaders, they recognize their own helpless rage and ignorance. In angry demagogues, they find the embodiment of a sovereignty they have been denied.'
If you’ve been half awake for the past decades, it’s obvious that we have efficiently and comfortably managed ourselves and the planet to the brink of collapse. The pandemic drags on. Public health messaging becomes more garbled. We see images on the margins of our feeds: Siberia is on fire.
What does the conspiritualist offer in a landscape of total existential dread? They offer total solutions. Not another COVID update, masking ordinance, or policy tweak. No rearrangement of deck chairs on the Titanic."
When grifters are not entirely wrong, we have work to do.