12/12/2025
We work with so many children and young people who are unable to "cope" with school. The problem is The System, NOT our young people. Compliance through fear has no place in education. âšď¸
The safeguarding review into Mossbourne Victoria Park Academy makes for distressing reading. It describes a harsh disciplinary culture, where pupils were frequently shouted at and humiliated. Yet even in this review, the school is praised for its âexcellent resultsâ.
And herein lies the problem. Because a school where pupils are afraid and unhappy, but which gets high grades at GCSEs, can be said to have âexcellent resultsâ. Our childrenâs lives have been reduced to exam scores. A schoolâs performance has been reduced to the same.
Unfortunately, this has led to harsh and high control environments across the country. Itâs not just Mossbourne. I hear about similar cultures in schools from the North to the South. Because, it turns out, an effective way for a school to get higher exam scores is to rigidly control every aspect of a childâs life, drill them relentlessly on how to take tests and harshly discipline those who donât comply. What we never ask is whether those high GCSE grades are really worth it.
For in my opinion we should be judging a school on so much more than test scores.
We should be asking whether a school produces confident and happy young people. We should be asking whether they leave school enthusiastic about learning and life. We should be asking whether they feel part of their community, and whether they are full of ideas as to what theyâd like to do. We should be asking whether they leave school feeling that their voice matters, and that they are people who can make a difference. We should ask if theyâve met adults who inspire them to take risks and push themselves.
That is what âexcellent resultsâ should really be. Young people who are ready to start adult life. Those are the results that really matter, and that is what, in my opinion, makes an outstanding school. Even if those young people do not get top grades at GCSE.
But to prioritise that, we will have to accept that exam results will not be as high as they might have been. We will have to accept that the cost of âexcellent resultsâ can be too high.
Just as it was at Mossbourne Academy, where the âexcellent resultsâ were at the cost of the young people themselves, and created a culture of fear. Results like this are very far from âexcellentâ.
https://www.theguardian.com/education/2025/dec/09/london-academy-staff-instilled-climate-of-fear-among-pupils #:~:text=The%20report%20by%20Sir%20Alan,harsh%20and%20damaging%20disciplinary%20culture