02/08/2023
The death of Sinead OāConnor and narrative in the mass media about her ābattling her demonsā have highlighted an important problem. When people speak out in rage against the system (in her case, famously, the Pope) they are often labelled hysterical or, worse, mentally unwell. Usually mental illness is a result of battling too long against something that canāt be resolved (in her case it was abuse).
Poor mental health mostly results from us experiencing events that have been traumatic or difficult. NOT because people themselves are fundamentally flawed.
And what those suffering need most is deep listening, understanding and compassion.
Itās not āthemā it is āall of usā. All that separates each of us from struggling is a series of events which we are unable to resolve.
Remember:
- Mental health is not āthe problemā, the life events and abuses that happened to those of us who are struggling (often at the hands of others) are the problem.
- Medical diagnoses such as bipolar, PTSD, depression do not make someone broken or a problem, the events that have caused them to struggle are the problem.
When we act like the person is the problem, or only see their label, we stop seeing the real human inside. Ditto if we ignore or minimise or try to explain away what they are feeling.
Sharing this brilliant article on Sinead OāConnor which brings out some of these themes and reclaims her experience not as one where she is the problem but the problem is with the system around her.
In her tragic passing, I choose to honor her by raising up these words she said, by hearing and believing them.