13/04/2025
Case presented by Samuel Hahnemann.
Patient Summary:
A woman with long-standing, right-sided facial pain and headaches. The pain is neuralgic, worse at night and in cold weather, better from warmth. She craves eggs and feels irritable and restless.
Homeopathic Analysis
1. Totality of Symptoms
Location & Sensation: Right-sided facial neuralgia, sharp, stabbing pain.
Modalities: Worse at night and in cold weather; better with warmth.
Generals: Irritability, restlessness, specific food craving (eggs).
Chronology: Long-standing condition (chronic).
2. Key Remedy: Spigelia anthelmia
Known For: Right-sided neuralgia, especially involving the face, eyes, and temples.
Pains: Sharp, shooting, or stabbing—often described like electric shocks.
Modalities: Worse from cold, movement, and touch; better from warmth and lying with head high.
Emotional State: Restless, anxious, sometimes irritable.
Food Desires: While not a keynote, some Spigelia patients show odd or strong cravings.
Remedy Choice Justification
The key rubric features here:
Facial Neuralgia (right-sided) + shooting pain
Worse at night/cold + better with warmth
Restlessness and irritability
Hahnemann’s choice of Spigelia fits well because of the tight alignment between the modalities and the nature of the pain. This remedy is often seen in neuralgic and rheumatic cases that are periodic and have distinct patterns.
Outcome
Improvement after the first dose showed accurate remedy selection.
Continued dosing over time brought full relief without needing to change remedies.
Emotional restlessness faded alongside physical pain—again affirming Hahnemann’s belief in the interconnection of mind and body.
Hahnemann likely chose the remedy based on a close match between the characteristics of the headache and the modalities and symptoms in the Spigelia materia medica.
Reasons for prescribing Spigelia typically include:
1. Location and character of the pain:
Pain often starts in the left temple or eye, radiating to the occiput.
Headache described as neuralgic, stabbing, or burning, often in one-sided (left-sided) pattern.
Sensation as if the head would burst.
2. Modalities (what makes it better or worse):
Worse from motion, touch, and stooping.
Worse with eye movement, noise, and mental exertion.
Often worse in the morning or at noon, and relieved in the evening.
3. Associated symptoms:
Eye strain, or headaches involving the orbital region.
May include palpitations or neuralgic pains elsewhere.
Hypersensitivity to noise and light.
4. Miasmatic background (psoric or sycotic tendencies):
Hahnemann would consider the miasmatic foundation, and if the patient had recurring headaches without identifiable acute cause, he might classify it under a chronic psoric condition.
So, Hahnemann prescribed Spigelia in such a case not just for “headache” as a diagnosis, but because the complete symptom picture—location, sensation, modalities, and perhaps other associated symptoms—matched that of Spigelia in his materia medica and provings.