
05/09/2025
Barefoot vs. Cushioned Shoes: Key Differences and Considerations
Barefoot (Minimalist) Shoes
Benefits:
- Encourage a natural gait and forefoot/midfoot striking, which may lead to lower impact forces and improved running mechanics for some runners.
- Promote strengthening of foot and lower leg muscles, which helps develop stability, proprioception, and potentially reduces certain kinds of running injuries related to weak foot muscles.
- Heightened ground feel and sensory feedback, enhancing balance and agility.
Risks:
- Increased risk of pain or injury on hard surfaces, long distances, or with high-arched/supinated feet, especially if transitioning too quickly or with poor technique. Stress fractures can occur if the body isn’t adequately conditioned.
- Not everyone benefits—runners with specific biomechanical issues, or those who don’t gradually adapt, may experience higher injury risk.
Cushioned Shoes
Benefits:
- Absorb impact, protect the feet from hard surfaces, and can enhance comfort especially on concrete or rocky terrain.
- May enable improved running speed and endurance: elite runners often use highly cushioned shoes, with some studies showing 2–4% performance gains at top speeds.
- Preferred for those with high-arched feet or whose natural biomechanics don’t provide sufficient shock absorption).
Risks:
- Do not necessarily reduce injury rates—despite decades of cushioned shoe use, annual injury rates have not significantly decreased; suggesting injuries are more related to gait/form and training than to shoe type alone.
- May promote a rearfoot (heel) strike, leading to altered joint angles and impact forces, which could contribute to more knee injuries or inefficient mechanics for some runners.