05/08/2024
Itâs so hard when our children want to quit things they start. But itâs most likely just not the right âthingâ or not the right teacher/coach.
Donât be afraid to listen to your children!
âI wish my parents had made me stick at things â so I wonât let my children quit.â
I hear this a lot. Whether itâs about reading a book which bores them, doing swimming lessons they detest, or taking exams in subjects they have no interest in, our belief that children must be made to stick at things they dislike runs deep. We look at our own lives and wish that we were more accomplished musicians, better at completing boring tasks, or more motivated to clean our houses â and we make our children stick at the things which we feel we lack.
It's all based on an error. That error is the idea that by forcing someone to do something, we will ultimately make them want to do (and even enjoy) that thing. That if we make our children stick at piano lessons, the day will come when they play for pleasure. That if we insist that they finish their book, theyâll acquire a love of reading.
This may happen sometimes, but mostly I hear about it going the other way. The moment they grow too big to be forced, they stop. Years of encouragement and lessons go for nothing, because they donât want to do it anymore.
Why? Well, when we insist, we change our childrenâs relationship with what they are doing. For there is a profound difference between choosing to do something (and being able to quit) and being made to do something (and therefore being stuck). Even something which was enjoyable when they could choose becomes tedious when itâs imposed upon them. Doing the most difficult and challenging work is fun when you do it because it has value to you, whilst even doing easy tasks takes forever when you feel that you have no choice.
What are we really saying, when we say we wish our parents had made us stick at things? Mostly, I think, weâre saying we wish we could do that thing, without having to put in the effort now. We wish we could play the piano, or swim triathlons, or finish every book we start â and we imagine another us, who spent their childhood diligently perfecting those skills for the benefit of our present-day selves.
Thatâs an idealised fantasy. Forcing kids to stick at things has unpredictable consequences and nothing is guaranteed. Making people do things changes their relationship with what they do.
Our children need the right to quit and make decisions about their lives, just as we do ourselves.
(Before you start talking about swimming lessons, I do understand how important learning to swim is but it is possible to learn to swim without lessons, and itâs also possible to switch swimming teacher and find that itâs an entirely different experience).