26/10/2025
You've been told to "eat more protein."
But not all protein is created equal.
..especially when it comes in a scoop.
And these tests suggest plant-based protein might be more harm than good: ⚠️👇
Protein powders have skyrocketed in popularity in recent years. 📈
And for good reason:
- Protein is more filling.
- Protein takes more energy to digest.
- Protein provides your body with essential building blocks.
And protein powders make it super easy. ✅
But...
This recent Consumer Reports investigation just dropped a bombshell: 👇
‼️Most protein powders are contaminated with toxic heavy metals... and it's not pretty.‼️
What CR tested:
→ 23 protein powders and ready-to-drink shakes
→ Products ranged from dairy (whey) to beef to plant-based
→ They used multiple samples of each product, and tested independently
What CR tested for:
→Lead
→Arsenic
→Cadmium
The key findings:
‼️ 70% of products exceeded CR’s daily lead limit
‼️ Some hit 10x the safe level in a single scoop
‼️Average lead levels were higher than in CR’s 2010 test (getting worse)
‼️ Fewer products had undetectable levels of lead
‼️ Plant-based proteins had 9x more lead than whey on average
The most alarming offenders:
⚠️ Naked Nutrition’s Vegan Mass Gainer:
- 1,570% of CR's daily lead limit
- 7.7 micrograms of lead per serving
⚠️ Huel Black Edition (Plant-Based):
- 1,290% of CR's lead limit
- Also had double the safe limit for cadmium
⚠️ Momentous 100% Plant Protein:
- 476% of lead limit per serving
- CR says: Use no more than once per week
How and WHY does this happen?
1⃣ Many plant proteins (pea, rice, h**p) absorb heavy metals from contaminated soil
2⃣ These metals accumulate in the body over time
And the worst part:
⚠️Lead, arsenic, cadmium are ALL linked to: ⚠️
- Neurotoxicity
- Kidney damage
- Immune suppression
- Hormonal disruption
- Reproductive problems
Whey isn’t immune either:
Some whey products, like Optimum Nutrition's Serious Mass, tested high in inorganic arsenic.
But overall: 👇
Dairy-based powders had the lowest heavy metal content.
Plant had the highest, by far.
The regulation gaps:
1⃣ Protein powders are not regulated like drugs.
2⃣ The FDA does not require testing for heavy metals.
3⃣ There are no enforceable federal limits for lead in supplements.
4⃣ So brands can legally sell contaminated products—and most do
The bottom line is:
⭐️ BE CAREFUL WITH YOUR SUPPLEMENTS.
Especially if you're drinking plant-based because you think it's "healthier." 🙄
What to do instead:
✅ Choose products with NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport labels
✅ Rotate or limit usage of plant-based powders
✅ Prioritize whole-food protein when possible
✅ Don’t rely on powders as a primary protein source
Remember:
Even “clean” brands are not safe (unless third-party tested).
Marketing does NOT equal safety. ❌
Be smart and do your research.