13/09/2022
毛孩腫瘤常見問題Part 1 (Cancer in Pets FAQ Part 1)
希望大家過了一個愉快嘅中秋假期。這幾天收到不少主人問相同嘅問題,我係呢到做個綜合。
1) 惡性腫瘤有甚麼治療方案?
- 動物現有嘅例如手術,放射治療,化療,標靶治療,免疫治療 (發展階段),熱消融治療,冷凍治療,補品食療(中西配方), 微創介入治療 (發展階段)
2) 放射治療係咪對動物係全新療程 ?
- 唔係。1906年,一位德國科學家及獸醫嘗試用放射治療去醫動物. 隨著多年嘅發展, 已經去到今時今日嘅設備同先進技術. 美國嘅獸醫大學同醫院好早期已經有得做放射治療. 早年嘅時候,都有主人帶埋寶貝飛去個邊去醫. 慶幸嘅係,香港今日終於有得做.
3) 我隻小狗/貓有腫瘤。我想進行放射治療,不想進行手術. 可以嗎 ?
- 雖然我講過,放射治療理論上係可以用係唔同位置或唔同惡性腫瘤. 但要記得,每一種癌症,都有自身不同地方。就算係同一種癌症,在身體其他位置都會有不同反應。每一位毛孩亦處於不同年齡,品種,性別,身體狀況及結構。******所以,每一隻腫瘤做完放射療程,反應效果係會唔同。 每一位治療方案係需要針對佢情況已定,沒有一套統一的. ******
如果個腫瘤係鼻腔,一定考慮放射治療。如果係一個高風險手術位置, 手術未必有效清除,例如腦,心臟,頸部接近大動脈, 咁係絕對可以考慮放射治療. 如果腫瘤係一個適合做手術嘅位置,但基於種種原因, 主人反對手術,例如口腔腫瘤,需要切部份或全個上下顎,或牽涉截肢嘅骨癌, 咁係絕對可以考慮放射治療.
舉個簡單例子: 一隻9歲金毛尋回犬不幸係背脊有惡性腫瘤A. 如果無擴散,視乎大少同粘連情況, 我建議做手術大範圍切割, +/- 化療, +/- 免疫治療 + 補品食療
同一隻金毛尋回犬係左前手有惡性腫瘤A, 由於很難100%切除 (除非主人同意截肢), 否則我會建議手術切割, 加放射治療, +/- 化療, +/- 免疫治療 + 補品食療.
同一隻金毛尋回犬係左前手有惡性腫瘤A, 但已經擴散到肝,肺部, 咁究竟做手術或放射治療成效有幾多 ? 我會建議做+/- 化療, +/- 免疫治療, + 補品食療.
以上嘅例子,如果我改成一隻更年老嘅貓狗, 身體有其他問題, 麻醉高風險, 或者係惡性腫瘤BCDEF, 加埋唔同嘅惡性級別 (Grading)同期數(staging, 早期,晚期), 咁我以上建議嘅療程又會有改變.
*******所以, 唔好混淆,因為朋友隻毛孩做到某個治療,唔代表其他可以.*******
4) 我隻小狗/貓可唔可以做幾個唔同嘅治療方案?
- 同上面一樣,視乎個位病人嘅情況而定。當然,若果治療配合多方面,控制腫瘤固然會好啲,但唔代表你100%做晒全部以上治療就係最有效/對佢最好!!!! 如果腫瘤比較大粒或者係一個比較難切除乾淨嘅位置, 牽涉太多重要神經及血管,可以先做放射治療縮細, 再做手術. 另一種情況係先做手術,但我知道係無可能100%切除, 後續我會再加放射治療 +/-其他.
5) 如果我選擇咩都唔做,可以嗎 ?
- 先澄清, 無野係叫’ 咩都唔做’. 因為’咩都唔做’, 由得佢自生自滅係好殘忍, 作為主人點可以忍心見到自己家庭一份子受苦. 因為動物唔識表達, 只可以依靠你地去做判斷. *****每一位主人對惡性腫瘤同生命嘅睇法都唔同, 所以做嘅決定都會唔同, 但要尊重大家. 最重要係保持毛孩生活質素 (quality of life). 可能主人會擔心麻醉,種種治療嘅副作用或其他考慮因素. 就算唔選擇以上嘅治療, 無論點都應該要做紓緩治療 (palliative care). *******
紓緩治療可以包括補品食療(中西配方), 同藥物治療. 如果佢痛,止痛。佢肚屙,止屙。唔食嘢,要餵食。如果唔得,嘗試開胃藥。都唔得,可能要镇静裝餵食管. 我地一定有方法令佢舒服.
唔好擔心自己嘅睇法, 同主診醫生商量. 如果你睇醫生,我係用專業知識解答你嘅問題,同一時間,我亦以主人身份同你分析究竟你應該點行下一步. 你要話比我聽你想治療去到幾盡,我地一齊幫毛孩走過難關. 陪佢哋多啲。動物其實好有性。佢地知呢場戰鬥,有你地陪伴係佢嘅動力.
如果去到差唔多時候,生活質素已經好差, 可以商量比唔比佢舒服咁離去.
6) 我隻小狗/貓可唔可以食呢款補品食療?
- 如果你地留意以上所有治療,無論你選擇做或唔做,你會發現補品食療係唯一一個咩情況下都會做. 好多時候,主人未見醫生之前亦都自行開始比毛孩唔同種類嘅supplements。 經 Dr Google 及朋友介紹,實在有太多資訊。 我會建議主人可以同醫生商量, 研究每一位毛孩適唔適合食用. Supplements 每個月都有新野, 有啲時候醫生都未接觸過. 所以主人可以同醫生分享,咁可以有更多資料幫各位病人.
我無可能係呢個 post解釋所有補品食療. 詳細我會開一啲專講營養同補品食療嘅Post. 雖然表面上無乜副作用,但如果食多左或重複或相撞,可能會有反效果或者無用.
大家繼續努力!
I hope everyone had a fun and pleasant mid-Autumn Festival. I will summarize several common questions that I’ve encountered from pet owners over the past few days.
1) What are the different treatment modalities for cancer?
- As of now, treatment options include surgery, radiation therapy, chemotherapy, targeted therapy, immunotherapy (Trial stage), thermo-ablation, cryoablation, and dietary supplements/nutrition (Chinese and/or Western), interventional oncology (Developmental stage)
2) Is radiation therapy a new thing in animals?
- Nope. In 1906, a German Scientist and Veterinarian was the first to use radiation treatment in animals. Technological advances and expertise have occurred throughout the course of decades. Many Veterinary Universities and Hospitals in the United States have been treating pets with radiation treatment many years ago. Some pet owners in Hong Kong have even brought their beloved pets to the United States for radiation treatment. Luckily, this treatment modality is now available in Hong Kong.
3) My pet is diagnosed with cancer. I would like to proceed for radiation treatment but not surgery. Is this ok?
- As I’ve stated, every tumour is unique, and there are underlying differences in behaviour and prognosis even if it’s the same type of tumour in a different location. Every dog/cat possesses anatomical and physiological differences, and variations in breed, gender, age and health issues complicates the big picture further. Every tumour responds differently to the effects of radiation treatment. Hence, there is no universal treatment protocol. Each treatment plan should be tailor-made for the exact individual.
If the tumour resides in the nasal cavity, radiation treatment is the choice to go. If the tumour resides in an area where surgical resection is difficult or poses high risks, such as brain, heart, neck (close to vital structures), then radiation treatment can certainly be considered. If the tumour resides in an area where surgical resection is possible, but the owner refuses due to the invasiveness and concerns such as comestic reasons, such as oral cavity tumours requiring maxillectomy or mandibulectomy, or amputation due to bone tumours, then radiation treatment can certainly be considered.
Let’s have a look at 1 example. A 9-year-old Golden Retriever was diagnosed with a malignant tumour A on his back. If the tumour has not spread elsewhere, and depending on the size and associated adhesions, I would recommend surgical resection with wide margins, +/- chemotherapy, +/- immunotherapy + dietary/supplements.
If the same Golden Retriever is diagnosed with a malignant tumour A on his left forelimb, surgery would be unable to obtain clean margins, unless the entire limb is amputated. In this sense, if the owner refuses amputation, a better treatment may include surgery plus radiation treatment, +/- chemotherapy, +/- immunotherapy, + dietary/supplements.
If the same Golden Retriever is diagnosed with a malignant tumour A on his left forelimb, with distant metastasis (spread) to the liver and lungs, then how much would surgery and radiation treatment help in this case? I would recommend +/- chemotherapy, +/- immunotherapy, + dietary/supplements.
In the above examples, If the Golden Retriever is older, with co-morbidities, higher anaesthesia risk, or maybe it’s diagnosed with malignant tumour BCDEF, with further differences in grading and staging of the tumour, then obviously the above treatment plans would change. Hence, pet owners should be aware that, one treatment protocol does not fit all.
4) Can my dog/cat perform several different treatment modalities?
- Certainly. However, it depends on the patient’s situation as stated above. If we combine a multi-modal approach, then we can control the tumour more effectively. If the tumour is too large to be surgically resected, plus proximity to nearby vital nerves and blood vessels, then a protocol involving radiation treatment first to shrink the tumour, followed by surgical resection, makes sense. Another example would be: if the surgeon knows it is impossible to resect the tumour 100% on the first surgery, then it maybe necessary to add further treatment such as radiation, +/- others.
5) If I choose to do nothing, is this ok?
- First, I need to clarify that there is no such thing as ‘doing nothing’. If we do nothing, it is cruel to the animal itself. As owners, it is devastating to see a part of our family member suffer. As pets are unable to effectively communicate with us, they rely on pet owners to make every decision and judgement. However, every owner may have different definitions or perceptions towards life itself or treating cancer. Hence, every owner’s decision making will be different, and this is something we should respect. The most important thing, however, is to maintain the pet’s quality of life, regardless of what you choose. With the above treatment modalities, you maybe worried of the anaesthetic risks, side effects from various treatments or other considerations. However, even if you do not choose any of the above aggressive treatment options, you should continue to go for palliative care.
Palliative care includes dietary/supplements, medications. If the pet is painful, treat the pain. If diarrhoea occurs, treat the diarrhoea. If he/she does not eat, assist feeding. If that doesn’t help, try appetite stimulants. If both aren’t helping, it may even be necessary to give him/her a sedation and insert a feeding tube. There are ways to make pets feel better.
Do not worry about your own thoughts or opinions. Do speak openly to the veterinarian in charge. If you come for a consultation, I am using my professional knowledge to solve your questions. At the same time, I am standing on a pet owner’s perspective to guide you in the decision-making process. You need to let me know how aggressive you want to fight this battle, and we will help the pet alongside. Stay with them more often, as animals can feel that you are supporting them, and this support is vital during this tough time.
When the time has come, and quality of life has deteriorated, it maybe necessary to discuss letting go and putting him to sleep.
6) Can my pet receive this type of supplement/food?
- If you noticed the above different treatment options, you could see that, regardless of whether you choose to pursue them, there is one option where you can always use, and that is nutritional supplements/food. Most owners have even started giving their pets various types of supplements before seeing the vet. There is a plethora of information from friends and Dr Google. I recommend a discussion with the vet to ensure our pets are having the proper nutrition and supplements for his condition/disease. Numerous supplements exist and they are produced at a faster rate than ever. Sometimes, vets may not have seen or heard such products before. Hence, it would be a good idea for the owner to share these supplements so that we are better able to decide and investigate its use for the patient.
It is impossible for me to talk about the types of food and supplements that are suitable for each individual patient here. I will have to cover these sections in detail in a few other posts. For now, do bear in mind that having an excess of supplements or inappropriate combinations can sometimes makes things worse, or render the treatment useless.
Stay strong !
#動物腫瘤治療 #動物放射治療 #動物癌症 #豐盈動物腫瘤中心 #免疫治療 #放射治療 #外科 #食療 #腫瘤 #寵物 #貓狗 #毛孩 #舒緩治療