11/10/2025
https://www.brutimes.com/news/health/who-is-truly-responsible-for-the-madhya-pradesh-cough-syrup-tragedy
क्या इस डॉक्टर को जेल भेजना सही है? डॉ.अभिषेक शुक्ला की इस बहस को पढ़ें और अपनी राय दें।
brutimes.com/news/health/wh…
Who Is Truly Responsible for the Madhya Pradesh Cough Syrup Tragedy?
The recent tragedy in Madhya Pradesh, where thirteen children lost their lives after consuming a cough syrup, has once again exposed the cracks in our healthcare and pharmaceutical regulation systems. The story is as heartbreaking as it is infuriating. A medication meant to ease a child’s cough became the cause of their death. And yet, instead of fixing accountability where it belongs, we seem to be targeting the easiest scapegoat, the doctor who prescribed it.
While the prescribing physician now sits behind bars, the company responsible for manufacturing the syrup has reportedly been given a clean chit. This inverted justice demands urgent scrutiny. It forces us to ask a simple but uncomfortable question- Who is really responsible when a medicine turns into poison?
Medicine doesn’t begin at the doctor’s desk. It begins much earlier, in factories where raw materials are mixed, purified, and tested; in laboratories where batches are certified for safety, in warehouses where they are stored, and in regulatory offices where licenses and approvals are stamped. Each link in this chain carries an enormous ethical and legal responsibility.
When that chain breaks, when a toxic chemical like diethylene glycol contaminates a cough syrup, the doctor is the last and least powerful link. He or she prescribes based on trust, trust that the product is safe, approved, and properly tested. That trust has now been betrayed.
The deaths in Madhya Pradesh were reportedly caused by diethylene glycol, a compound used in industrial solvents and antifreeze, known to cause kidney failure and death. Such contamination is not new. India has witnessed similar tragedies before, in Udhampur, Chennai, and even internationally in countries that imported Indian-made syrups. Each time, the root cause has been the same, a collapse of quality control and regulatory vigilance.
The expectation that a doctor must somehow verify the purity of every drug they prescribe is unreasonable and illogical. A physician can check the dose, suitability, and brand, but cannot chemically analyze each syrup bottle. That responsibility lies squarely with the manufacturer and the regulators.
Doctors prescribe medicines approved by the government and sold legally in pharmacies. They do so in good faith, guided by medical evidence. Punishing them for manufacturing lapses is both unjust and demoralizing. It sends a chilling message across the medical community, that even when you follow every rule, you can still be jailed for someone else’s failure.
If we continue on this path, doctors will begin to fear prescribing even essential medicines, especially for children. The result will be hesitation, under-treatment, and loss of trust in the healthcare system, outcomes no society can afford.
Where the Real Responsibility Lies
1.Manufacturing Units:
The contamination could only occur if the manufacturer used unsafe raw materials or skipped standard purification and testing steps. Quality control protocols exist precisely to detect toxic adulterants. If those checks failed or were ignored, the manufacturer bears primary responsibility.
2.Suppliers of Raw Materials:
Pharmaceutical-grade solvents are expensive. Unscrupulous suppliers sometimes substitute cheaper, industrial-grade alternatives. It is the duty of the company to test every batch before production. Failure to do so is criminal negligence.
3.Drug Regulators:
Regulatory bodies must act as the watchdogs of public health. Approving drugs, inspecting plants, and testing samples are their core functions. Yet, in this case, early public statements reportedly gave the syrup a “clean chit” before conclusive lab results were released. Such haste erodes public confidence and weakens accountability.
through reform.
The recent tragedy in Madhya Pradesh, where thirteen children lost their lives after consuming a cough syrup, has once again exposed the cracks in our healthcare and pharmaceutical regulation systems.