13/09/2024
你需要知道的医护人员分类
最近我去做身体检查时,因我在职业栏里填了“心理师”(psychologist),那位收银员便直接称呼我为“陈医生”(Dr. Chan)。但我既不是医学医生(medical doctor),也没有博士学位(Doctor of Philosophy, PhD),于是赶紧澄清我只是“陈女士”。十多年前,当我还担任特教老师时,就已经常与家长解释各种医护人员的分类。令我惊讶的是,这么多年过去了,公众对这方面的了解依然不足。因此,我希望通过这篇文章让大家对医护职业有更多的认识。由于种类繁多,这里我仅介绍与我工作密切相关的医护人员。
首先,医护职业可以分为两大类:
1. 医疗人员 (Health practitioners)
这类包括我们常见的医生、护士和牙医。他们具备医学知识,主要从事与健康照护相关的治疗。在马来西亚,所有医生都必须在政府注册,只有注册医生才能为患者申请残障卡(Kad Orang Kurang Upaya)。
a. 儿科医生 (Paediatricians)
儿科医生属于医疗人员,他们经过基础医学训练后,继续深造成为专门治疗儿童的医生。然而,由于儿童疾病涵盖范围广,并非所有儿科医生都对儿童发展的差异有深入了解。发展儿科医生(Developmental Paediatricians)在这方面知识更为专精,但在我国这种医生非常少见。
b. 精神科医生 (Psychiatrists)
和其他专科医生一样,精神科医生经过基础医学训练和专科训练。许多人会将精神科医生与心理师混淆。一方面是因为在我们的社会中,许多人避免看“精神科”,认为只有神经病(如有幻觉的人)才需要看精神科医生。因此,一些精神科医生将职称改为“心理医生”,以减少患者因避讳而不寻求帮助。由于我国没有官方中文翻译,这种做法无可厚非,但也导致公众误以为存在“心理医生”这一职业。事实上,帮助精神疾病患者(包括常见的忧郁症、焦虑症等)的医护人员只有“精神科医生”或“心理治疗师/心理学家”。
那这两者有什么区别呢?一般来说,精神科医生主要专注于药物治疗。由于他们拥有深厚的医学知识,能够为患者开药。在马来西亚,如果你需要治疗多动症的药物,你需要看精神科医生。尽管一些精神科医生也学习了心理治疗的谈话技术,但这其实是心理治疗师/心理学家更擅长的领域。
2. 辅助医疗人员 (Allied Health Practitioners)
辅助医疗人员是提供药物之外的治疗来帮助患者恢复健康。只是他们没有接受医学训练,因此不能被称为“医生”。马来西亚自2022年起开始要求辅助医疗人员注册,但该规定并不完善,政府也并没有严格执行此规定。因此,仍有一些未注册或甚至是不具资格的人自称为治疗师。
a. 心理师/心理学家 (Psychologist)
实际上,心理学学士毕业生不能称为心理师,只有硕士或博士心理学毕业生才能称为心理学家。但心理学家分为执业心理学家(practice psychologist)和学术研究心理学家。前者可以注册并提供治疗,后者则专注于学术研究或在大学任教。
在马来西亚,大多数心理师的职称是临床心理师(Clinical Psychologist),这是因为在马来西亚,只有临床心理师硕士课程训练执业心理师。其他心理学硕士课程并未满足执业心理师的培训要求。为什么我们如此看重心理师是否具备执业资格?主要原因是执业心理师不仅需要学习理论,课程中的大部分时间都用于实习、评估个案、练习使用评估工具和撰写报告。事实上,大多数评估工具(如IQ测试)必须由持有执业执照的心理师使用(用于学术研究的情况除外)。
在某些国家,执业心理师还包括教育与发展心理师(Educational and Developmental Psychologist)或学校心理师(School Psychologist)。我本人就是其中之一。我们的训练与临床心理师相似,区别在于临床心理师更专注于治疗精神/心理疾病,而我们则更专注于发展差异和学习问题。遗憾的是,目前马来西亚的教育心理学硕士学位未获认可,政府也不允许非临床心理学家注册。因此,我只能继续使用国外的注册执照。
当然,除了上述两类心理师,还有神经心理师(Neuropsychologist)、辅导心理师(Counselling psychologist)、犯罪心理师(Forensic psychologist)等。由于篇幅有限,这里不详细讨论。
整体而言,心理师通过面谈来治疗个案的心理问题,他们也负责评估和诊断精神疾病及各种发展差异。
b. 语言治疗师 (Speech Language Pathologist/Speech Therapist)
许多人认为语言治疗师只是教人如何说话,但他们的工作范围远不止于此。他们负责人与人之间的沟通问题。如果患者发音有障碍,他们会帮助纠正发音。如果患者完全无法使用语言,他们会教导使用辅助与替代性沟通方式(Augmentative Alternative Communication, AAC),如图片或平板电脑。他们还负责教导词汇和造句,有些语言治疗师也处理咀嚼和吞咽问题。
c. 职能治疗师 (Occupational Therapist)
从名称来看,职能治疗师的工作是帮助个案恢复“职业”功能。你可能会好奇,孩子有什么“职业”需要看职能治疗师呢?孩子的职业是玩耍、学习和自我照顾。所以,当孩子无法做到这些时,就可以寻求职能治疗师的帮助。他们的工作与物理治疗师有些重叠,也训练患者的粗大和精细动作。不同的是,职能治疗师的重点是帮助患者自理和恢复工作能力,而物理治疗师则是着重于加强患者的身体肌肉。对于有发展差异的儿童,职能治疗师能够帮助孩子提高专注力、自理能力、身体协调和握笔能力,还能处理他们感觉异常的问题。
当然,还有一些其他相关职业并未包括在上述分类中:
1. 辅导员 (Counsellor)
在马来西亚,辅导员需要在国家注册。辅导员的工作与临床心理师有些相似,但辅导员的训练更专注于通过面谈帮助个案解决生活中的问题。相比之下,临床心理师倾向于治疗心理和精神疾病,如抑郁症、焦虑症、强迫症等。
2. 其他治疗师 (Therapists)
这些治疗师通常不需要注册。一般来说,只需参加短期课程就可以称为治疗师,这包括行为治疗师(Behaviour Therapists/ABA Therapists)、游戏治疗师(Play Therapists)、艺术治疗师(Art Therapists)等等。但有些辅导相关的治疗师也同时持有辅导员或临床心理师的执照。
事实上,没有哪个职业比另一个更高级,虽然公众普遍认为接受教育和训练时间越长,医护人员的能力越强。因此,医生通常比心理师更受尊敬,心理师又比辅导员更受看重。但拥有高等训练并不代表一定更好。我个人更鼓励大家寻找适合自己的治疗师,无论他们是哪一类的医护人员。关键是,他们没有虚假使用职称(如只有心理学学士毕业却自称心理治疗师),也没有超出自己受训范围进行治疗或使用未经科学验证的方法。不要仅凭收费高低(收费高并不一定代表更好)或他人推荐。在我国政府能够有效监管各类医护人员之前,我只能希望大家在寻求帮助前,先了解专业人士的背景,再做决定是否应该求助于该人。
Categories of Healthcare Professionals You Should Know About
Recently, when I went for a medical check-up and listed my occupation as "psychologist", the cashier immediately addressed me as "Dr. Chan." However, I am neither a medical doctor nor do I hold a PhD, so I quickly clarified that I am "Ms. Chan." More than a decade ago, when I was still a special education teacher, I frequently explained the classification of healthcare professionals to parents. I was surprised to find that after all these years, the public's understanding in this area is still quite limited. Therefore, I hope to use this article to help people better understand healthcare professions. Given the wide range of professions, I will only cover those closely related to my work.
First, healthcare professions can be divided into two main categories:
1. Health Practitioners
This group includes the doctors, nurses, and dentists we commonly see. They possess medical knowledge and primarily engage in medical treatments related to health care. In Malaysia, all doctors must be registered with the government, and only registered doctors can assist patients in applying for a disability card (Kad Orang Kurang Upaya).
a. Paediatricians
Paediatricians are health practitioners. After completing basic medical training, they continue their studies to specialise in treating children. However, because childhood diseases cover a broad spectrum, not all paediatricians have in-depth knowledge of developmental differences in children. Developmental paediatricians specialise in this area, but they are very rare in Malaysia.
b. Psychiatrists
Like other specialists, psychiatrists undergo basic medical training followed by specialised training. Many people confuse psychiatrists with psychologists. One reason for this is that, in our society, many avoid seeing a “psychiatrist”, thinking that only people with severe mental disorders (e.g., hallucinations) need to see one. As a result, some psychiatrists change their title to "psychological doctors" in Chinese to prevent patients from avoiding seeking help. Since there is no official Chinese translation for these titles in our country, this practice is understandable. However, it also leads the public to believe that a profession called "psychological doctor" exists. In fact, the only professionals who help people with mental illnesses (including common conditions such as depression and anxiety) are psychiatrists or psychologists.
So, what’s the difference between these two professions? Generally, psychiatrists focus more on medication. Because they have extensive medical knowledge, they are qualified to prescribe drugs. In Malaysia, if you need medication for ADHD, you must see a psychiatrist. Although some psychiatrists have also learned talk therapy techniques, this is more the expertise of psychologists.
2. Allied Health Practitioners
Allied health practitioners provide non-medical treatments to assist patients in their recovery. Since they don’t undergo medical training, they are not referred to as “doctors.” In Malaysia, a registration requirement for allied health practitioners was introduced in 2022. However, this regulation is not well-enforced, and there are still unregistered or even unqualified individuals claiming to be therapists.
a. Psychologists
In reality, psychology graduates with just a bachelor's degree cannot call themselves psychologists. Only those with a master’s or doctoral degree in psychology can do so. However, psychologists can be divided into practice psychologists (who are licensed to provide therapy) and academic psychologists (who focus on research and teaching). In Malaysia, most psychologists hold the title of Clinical Psychologist. This is because in our country, only the master's program in clinical psychology offers training for practice psychologists. Other psychology master's programs do not meet the training requirements for practice.
Why do we place so much importance on whether a psychologist has practice qualifications? The main reason is that practicing psychologists not only study theory, but they also spend a large portion of their training seeing clients, using assessment tools, and writing reports. In fact, most assessment tools (like IQ tests) must be administered by a licensed psychologist (unless used for academic research).
In some countries, practicing psychologists also include educational and developmental psychologists or school psychologists. I am one of these. Our training is similar to that of clinical psychologists, except that clinical psychologists focus more on treating mental/psychological illnesses, while we focus more on developmental differences and learning problems. Unfortunately, Malaysia’s master’s programs in educational psychology are not yet accredited, and the government does not allow non-clinical psychologists to register. Thus, I have to continue using my registration from abroad.
Of course, besides these two types of psychologists, there are neuropsychologists, counselling psychologists, forensic psychologists, and others. Due to space limitations, I won’t go into detail here.
In general, psychologists work through talk therapy to address clients’ mental health issues. They also assess and diagnose mental illnesses and developmental differences.
b. Speech-Language Pathologists/Speech Therapists
Many people think speech therapists only teach people how to speak, but their scope of work is much broader. They handle communication issues. If someone has trouble with pronunciation, they help correct it. If a person cannot use language at all, they teach clients to use augmentative alternative communication (AAC), such as using pictures or tablets. They also teach vocabulary and sentence formation. Some speech therapists also address chewing and swallowing issues.
c. Occupational Therapists
From the name, you might think occupational therapists help people recover their “occupations.” You might wonder, what “occupation” does a child have that requires an occupational therapist? A child’s “occupation” is play, learning, and self-care. So, if a child struggles with these activities, they can seek help from an occupational therapist. Their work overlaps somewhat with physiotherapists, as they also train gross and fine motor skills. However, occupational therapists focus on helping patients regain self-help skills and work abilities, while physiotherapists focus more on strengthening muscles. For children with developmental differences, occupational therapists help improve focus, self-care skills, body coordination, and handwriting ability, as well as address challenges arise from sensory differences.
Additional Related Professions Not Included in the Above Categories:
1. Counsellors
In Malaysia, counsellors must be registered with the government. Their work is similar to that of clinical psychologists. However, counsellors are trained to help clients through talk therapy to address life issues. Clinical psychologists, on the other hand, tend to focus more on treating mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety, and obsessive-compulsive disorder.
2. Other Therapists
These therapists usually don’t need to be registered. Generally, after attending a short course, one can become a therapist. This category includes behaviour therapists (ABA therapists), play therapists, and art therapists. However, some counselling-related therapists may also hold a counsellor or clinical psychologist license.
In fact, no profession is inherently superior to another, although the public often assumes that the more education and training one has, the better they are. As a result, doctors are often more respected than psychologists, and psychologists more than counsellors. But higher education does not always guarantee better care. Personally, I encourage people to find the therapist who is right for them, regardless of the type of professionals. What matters most is that they are honest about their credentials (for example, not claiming to be a psychologist with only a bachelor’s degree in psychology), and that they stick to their area of expertise and avoid treatments that is not evidence-based. Do not judge solely based on fees (higher fees do not necessarily mean better) or by recommendations from others. Until the Malaysian government can effectively regulate all healthcare professionals, I hope everyone takes the time to understand the background of the professionals before deciding whether to seek their help.