
24/09/2024
The Pathologising of Behaviour and Medicating of Symptoms: Does it always work?
Six months ago, a mother attended sessions with her 14-year-old daughter.
Six medical assessments over seven years identified her behaviour as; defiance, rebellion, uncontrolled emotional outbursts and refusal to attend school. Aggression towards her mother included shouting, screaming, punching, kicking, physical violence, and smashing and breaking objects in the house. She not only repeatedly shouted that she hated her mother and wanted to kill her, but was also physically violent towards her younger brother. Her mother was a solo parent and was desperate to get the help that she needed for her daughter.
The reports included pregnancy, childbirth, and early years development history. It identified behavioural difficulties, separation anxiety, sensory sensitivity, mood disorders, hoarding, general anxiety disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, and obsessive-compulsive disorder. One report diagnosed ADHD, and another autism spectrum condition.
Treatment included prescribing several medications, including sertraline and risperidone, as well as CBT, DBT, social skills training, educational support and medication reviews.
In my interactions between mother and daughter, I witnessed a desperate attempt to get the mother's attention and a desire to punish her when she did. She was permanently conflicted between needing her mother and feeling a deep hatred towards her, which was violently expressed.
Although the reports mentioned the only trauma being her parent's separation when she was nine, my observations pointed to significant unprocessed grief and loss at two, when her brother arrived on the scene.
A child of fourteen cannot in talking therapy verbalise an experience at the age of two, but what was displayed through somatic work was a range of complex emotions, including anger, grief, fear, sadness, jealousy and abandonment, around the event.
The aim of sessions, therefore, was to help the child experience the loss of exclusivity, fear of replacement, a change in routine, grief for her old life, confusion around her emotions, tantrums, irritability, anger towards her sibling and hatred towards her mother.
Following a therapy programme through grief and loss therapy, creative therapy, somatic exercises, sensory modulation, polyvagal theory, and internal family systems, after only two months, there were no signs of destructive behaviour. In addition, the daughter reintegrated into school, and her relationship with her mum was re-established. The child felt seen and heard.
Therefore, my questions are: Why do we focus on pathologising behaviour when clients often need help putting into words an experience they cannot locate? Moreover, why do we still focus on behaviour control and management when it generally indicates an unresolved or underlying unmet need?
www.teenagetoolbox.com