02/04/2026
When you go to your doctor, do you ask them why your car makes a strange noise when you shift gears?
When you take your car to the mechanic, do you ask them for stock market investment advice?
When you talk to your financial advisor, do you ask them to diagnose that strange rash on the back of your neck?
Of course not.
You shouldn’t ask your Tai Chi or Qigong teacher any of these kinds of questions either.
Unless, of course, their day job just happens to be doctor, mechanic, or financial advisor.
The point is that just because someone is knowledgeable in Tai Chi or Qigong, that doesn’t make them a wise sage who can provide authoritative advice on any given topic under the sun.
I occasionally have students ask me for specific exercises for specific ailments they might be experiencing. Well, I’m not a doctor, so most of the time I say “I don’t know.”
If I’ve experienced the same or similar issues, I might talk about that and what worked for me, but I also explain that what worked for me might not work for them.
I don’t live in their body, so I don’t know what they are truly feeling.
I’m definitely not going to try and diagnose their condition. That kind of thing falls way, way outside my purview.
The same goes for financial advice, mental health or relationship counseling, career advice, etc.
I teach Tai Chi and Qigong, and I write essays on those and a few other topics on various platforms.
I’m not a life coach.
If you ask me as a friend, I might give you my honest opinion, but it carries no more weight than anyone else you might know.
In fact, I would warn you to be very cautious of Tai Chi or Qigong instructors (or teachers of anything related, such as other martial arts, yoga, meditation, or etc.) who are eager to offer up unqualified advice, maybe even with the expectation that you do exactly as they say.
You might think you’ve met your true guru, but it’s more likely that you’re falling under the influence of a de-facto cult leader.
Be careful with who you trust.