16/03/2026
This is very interesting and good points raised
Just because your horse didnโt respond to a bute trial doesnโt mean it isnโt in pain.
This important message came up during the recent Bova/Virbac roadshow, where discussions highlighted why veterinarians should be cautious about using a phenylbutazone (โbuteโ) trial as a way to rule out pain in horses.
A common approach when investigating behavioural concerns is to perform a bute trial to see if the behaviour improves. The reasoning is that if the horse improves on pain relief, pain may be involved. However, there are some important problems with this approach. If a horse responds positively to a bute trial, this can be useful information and often prompts further investigation into the source of discomfort. But if the horse does not respond, we cannot simply assume the issue is behavioural. A lack of response to bute does not reliably rule out pain.
During the roadshow, veterinary behaviour specialist Dr Gemma Pearson discussed this issue in detail. One of the key points she highlighted was that framing the problem as โpain vs behaviourโ is often overly simplistic. Many horses showing behavioural problemsโsuch as resistance under saddle, girthing issues, reluctance to move forward, or anxiety during handlingโmay have underlying physical discomfort contributing to the behaviour. In many cases, behaviour and pain are intertwined.
Another limitation is that not all pain in horses is inflammatory. Phenylbutazone works by reducing inflammation, but pain associated with neuropathic processes, muscle dysfunction, visceral disease, or chronic conditions may respond poorlyโor not at allโto bute.
Dr Pearson also outlined a useful diagnostic framework for veterinarians. Rather than relying on a single medication trial, a structured investigation is needed. This may include a combination of diagnostic and treatment approaches.
These investigations and treatment plans should always be tailored to the individual horse.
The key message is simple: if a horse is showing behaviour changes and a bute trial doesnโt help, it doesnโt mean pain isnโt involved. It may simply mean we need to look deeper to understand what the horse is trying to tell us. ๐ด
๐ฌ Never miss an update. Subscribe now for FREE!
https://avonridgeequine.aweb.page/exclusive-veterinary-insights
๐ฉบ Contact us on 0427 072 095 or book an appointment online: https://avonridgeequine.com.au/book-an-appointment/