04/11/2025
With the help of AI and clinical tests I came to this conclusion
Hypocapnia and Respiratory Regulation in ENS – A Likely Primary and Secondary Mechanism
I have hypocapnia, meaning abnormally low levels of carbon dioxide (CO₂) in the blood. I know that I exhale too much CO₂, but this is not because I take an unusually high number of breaths per minute – it’s because my breathing depth (tidal volume) is excessively large. My tidal volume at rest is over 1.3 liters, which is far above the normal ~0.5 liters at rest. I suspect this is because I ventilate much more air than is physiologically necessary, meaning that my breathing volume is disproportionate at rest.
🧠 Primary Cause: Loss of Nasal Function and Sensory Feedback
My theory is that this primarily results from the fact that my nose is wide open and has impaired sensory function after surgery (turbinate resection, possibly conchotomy). Since my turbinates have been removed or significantly reduced, I experience:
• No normal nasal resistance to slow airflow and support calm breathing
• Impaired trigeminal receptor function (mechanoreceptors, thermoreceptors, humidity sensors) that usually inform the brain about airflow, temperature, and breathing
• Loss of part of the body’s intrinsic ventilation regulation through nasal reflexes
This makes me unable to properly sense airflow, similar to how a person who does not produce the hunger hormone ghrelin may overeat because they don’t feel full. In the same way, I may “overbreathe” – that is, ventilate excessive amounts of air – because my brain doesn’t receive accurate feedback about how much air I am actually inhaling and exhaling.
This likely creates a form of primary hypocapnia, as a direct result of surgically induced dysfunction in the nose – both mechanically and neuro-sensorially.
🔁 Secondary Effect: Altered Chemoreceptor Sensitivity
I also believe that this has led to a secondary hypocapnia. When I live with low CO₂ for a long period, the body adapts. It’s well established that the chemoreceptors in the brainstem (and in the carotid bodies) can become desensitized to CO₂ during chronic hyperventilation. The brain and the respiratory centers reset their threshold, making the low CO₂ level seem normal, which then drives continued overbreathing – even when it would be physiologically better to breathe less.
This may create a vicious cycle:
1. Primarily, I breathe too deeply due to nasal structural and neurological issues.
2. Secondarily, the body adapts to the low CO₂ and thus drives further overventilation.
This means I need not only to correct what is physically wrong in my nose (e.g., through surgery, implants, or flow-regulating devices) – I also need to actively retrain my CO₂ tolerance and chemosensitivity in the respiratory centers, in order to break the secondary loop.
🫁 What’s Needed to Maintain CO₂ in the Blood
Carbon dioxide is produced in the body during metabolic processes and is removed through the lungs. To maintain a healthy CO₂ level at rest, breathing must be:
• Low-volume and calm (small breaths → more CO₂ is retained)
• Deep and fast only when needed, such as during physical activity (increased metabolic CO₂)
• Regulated by proper sensory input, such as normal nasal resistance that slows airflow
• Slow both on inhalation and exhalation, ideally through the nose
In ENS, several of these mechanisms are disrupted – particularly nasal resistance and trigeminal sensory feedback – making the body lack its natural braking system to keep breathing calm at rest.
✨ Conclusion
It is therefore fully reasonable to consider that both primary physical causes (loss of turbinates, sensory loss in the nose) and secondary neurophysiological causes (chemoreceptor adaptation due to chronically low CO₂) together contribute to my hypocapnia.
Long-term recovery should therefore include:
1. Measures to increase nasal resistance airflow perception and regulate airflow
2. Active training to restore the brain’s sensitivity to CO₂, such as through controlled breathing, nasal reconditioning, or CO₂ tolerance exercises
⸻
🧠 There are two main types of chemoreceptors involved in breathing regulation: central and peripheral
🔶 1. Central chemoreceptors (in the brain)
• Location: In the medulla oblongata, a part of the brainstem responsible for automatic functions like breathing, heart rate, and blood pressure.
• What they detect: Changes in the pH of cerebrospinal fluid, which reflects levels of carbon dioxide (CO₂) in the blood.
• How they work: If CO₂ levels in the blood rise → carbonic acid forms → pH drops → central chemoreceptors are activated → they signal the respiratory centers in the brainstem → breathing increases to expel more CO₂.
🌀 In cases of long-term low CO₂ levels (chronic hypokapnia), these receptors become less sensitive (desensitized). The brain begins to accept abnormally low CO₂ as normal, and the respiratory drive remains elevated, even when it shouldn’t be.
⸻
🔷 2. Peripheral chemoreceptors (outside the brain)
These are located in major blood vessels, directly exposed to circulating blood from the heart.
a) Carotid bodies (glomus caroticum)
• Location: At the bifurcation of the common carotid artery in the neck (below the jawline), one on each side.
• What they detect: Primarily low oxygen levels (hypoxia), but also changes in blood CO₂ and pH.
• How they work: They send signals to the brainstem through the glossopharyngeal nerve (cranial nerve IX).
b) Aortic bodies (glomus aorticum)
• Location: In the aortic arch, the large artery just after blood is pumped from the heart.
• What they detect: Similar to carotid bodies, but they are less sensitive to CO₂ compared to central chemoreceptors.
• How they work: They send signals via the vagus nerve (cranial nerve X).
⸻
🔄 What happens during prolonged low CO₂ (chronic hypokapnia)?
• The body adapts to functioning with low CO₂.
• Chemoreceptors, especially central ones, become desensitized – they no longer trigger a corrective response when CO₂ is low.
• The brain’s respiratory centers receive “false normal” signals, and the body continues to overbreathe.
• This creates a vicious cycle: overbreathing → CO₂ drops further → chemoreceptors adapt even more → overbreathing continues.
This is why recovery often requires both behavioral retraining (e.g. breathing techniques to retain CO₂) and restoring physiological feedback (e.g. through increasing nasal resistance or guided CO₂ retention).
⸻
Can IVAPS (Intelligent Volume-Assured Pressure Support) help for nightly hyperventilation.
🔹 How IVAPS Works
• IVAPS (Intelligent Volume-Assured Pressure Support) is a ventilation method that combines pressure support with a target for tidal volume or minute ventilation.
• The machine monitors your breathing continuously and adjusts the pressure support to ensure you receive the appropriate amount of air.
• It can therefore:
1. Prevent you from breathing too deeply (which lowers CO₂)
2. Help maintain tidal volume and minute ventilation within physiological ranges
3. Reduce the risk of nighttime awakenings triggered by hypocapnia and alkalosis
⸻
🔹 Potential Effects
1. More stable CO₂ levels
• By controlling your ventilation at night, the machine can help prevent CO₂ from dropping too low.
• This can break the vicious cycle where hypocapnia causes awakenings.
2. Reduced respiratory alkalosis
• Limiting over-ventilation can stabilize blood pH.
3. Better heart function and blood pressure
• Normal CO₂ → less vasoconstriction → lower blood pressure → improved oxygen delivery to the heart and muscles.
• Can reduce nighttime cardiac symptoms and muscle cramps.
⸻
🔹 Important Considerations
• IVAPS cannot repair the primary nasal problem or ENS, but it can manage the secondary effect of overbreathing.
• For optimal benefit, the settings must be carefully adjusted:
• Target minute ventilation / tidal volume
• Safety limits for pressure
• Tolerance for apneas or hypoventilation
• Its effect is maximized when combined with CO₂ tolerance training and nasal resistance adjustment.
⸻
🔹 Summary
A nighttime IVAPS machine could potentially control hyperventilation, stabilize CO₂ and pH, and thereby reduce nighttime awakenings. However, it should be monitored and adjusted by a physician experienced in respiratory disorders and ENS, with individualized settings.
⸻
CO₂ Breathing Exercises: Buteyko Method and Controlled CO₂ Training
The Buteyko Breathing Method
The Buteyko method is a breathing therapy designed to treat hyperventilation, asthma, and hypocapnia. Its main goal is to teach the body to tolerate higher CO₂ levels and reduce over-breathing.
Key principles of Buteyko:
1. Reducing over-breathing
• Many people with hyperventilation take too many breaths or too deep breaths, which lowers CO₂ in the blood and can cause symptoms like air hunger, dizziness, palpitations, and alkalosis.
• Buteyko emphasizes slow, shallow, and controlled breathing to maintain more normal CO₂ levels.
2. CO₂ tolerance training
• A central technique is breath-holds after exhalation:
1. Exhale slowly and completely.
2. Hold the breath until a slight urge to breathe appears.
3. Resume slow nasal breathing.
• This gradually trains the body to tolerate higher CO₂, reducing the drive to over-breathe.
3. Nasal breathing and slow exhalation
• Nasal breathing naturally creates resistance, which slows airflow and stabilizes CO₂.
• Long, gentle exhalations stimulate the parasympathetic nervous system, calming the body and stabilizing heart rate and blood pressure.
Typical training:
• Daily short sessions of 5–15 minutes
• Gradual increase in breath-hold tolerance
• Integrating calm nasal breathing throughout the day
Benefits:
• Reduces hyperventilation symptoms (air hunger, dizziness, palpitations)
• Improves CO₂ tolerance and stabilizes blood pH
• Promotes calmness and parasympathetic regulation
⸻
My Controlled CO₂ Breathing Method
My method is inspired by Buteyko but uses direct CO₂ inhalation (food-grade CO₂, the same type used in carbonated beverages) to increase the intensity and effectiveness of the training.
Step-by-step process:
1. Inhale CO₂-enriched air
• The goal is to raise CO₂ levels in the blood and create a strong feeling of air hunger.
• This trains the desensitized CO₂ receptors in the body to tolerate higher CO₂ levels.
2. Hold the breath
• Keep the CO₂ in your lungs for a short period until it begins to feel uncomfortable.
• This ensures the CO₂ receptors are actively stimulated, promoting adaptation.
3. Exhale slowly
• Slow exhalation activates the parasympathetic nervous system, helping the body calm down.
4. Two normal breaths
• Take two normal, slow breaths, exhaling gently and shallowly.
• This allows partial recovery while keeping CO₂ slightly elevated.
5. Repeat the cycle
• Inhale CO₂ again, hold, exhale slowly, then take normal breaths.
• Continue for approximately 10 minutes, aiming to gradually challenge CO₂ tolerance.
Signs that it’s working:
• A slight warmth in your hands and feet, indicating increased CO₂ in the body.
• A feeling of mental calmness after the exercise.
• Reduced sensation of air hunger for hours afterward.
⸻
Why This Method Works
1. Trains CO₂ receptors – makes the body more sensitive and responsive to normal CO₂ levels.
2. Stabilizes blood pH – reduces alkalosis, which lowers stress on the heart and muscles.
3. Activates the parasympathetic nervous system – promotes calmness, stabilizes heart rate, and reduces blood pressure.
4. Breaks the cycle of hyperventilation and air hunger – teaches the body to tolerate higher CO₂ without triggering excessive breathing.
⸻
Summary
Both Buteyko breathing and my controlled CO₂ method focus on training the body to tolerate higher CO₂ levels, reducing over-breathing and hyperventilation.
• Buteyko uses natural CO₂ buildup through breath-holds and nasal breathing.
• Controlled CO₂ breathing uses food-grade CO₂ to accelerate CO₂ training and make the body more tolerant.
The combined effects are:
• Reduced air hunger and hyperventilation
• Stabilized blood pH and cardiovascular function
• Mental calmness and parasympathetic activation
This approach is particularly useful for anyone suffering from chronic hyperventilation, hypocapnia, or difficulty maintaining normal breathing patterns.
⸻
