10/16/2024
R**E TRIAL IN EDWARDS COUNTY:
The Edwards County Courthouse in Albion, Illinois is usually a very quiet place. Once in awhile, a court case comes up that draws big public interest. That certainly was true when a r**e case came up in April of 1952. Two teenaged boys were accused of ra**ng a 17 year old girl at Moose Lake north of Albion on October 25, 1951. Newspapers in Albion and Mt. Carmel carried the story.
In statements given to police, the alleged victim said she had just gotten off work at the movie theatre in Albion. Because she knew the two boys, she explained that she accepted a ride home in their car. However, she said she was taken to Moose Lake located about 5 miles north of Albion. She further told authorities that the boys drew matches to decide who would go first. Gordon Gubbins, according to her, went first in ra**ng her. David Hollomon then took his turn in the backseat. During the ordeal, the girl said she was savagely beaten in her attempts to prevent the r**e. She said she was then driven home and told “don’t tell anyone because it’s the word of two fellows against yours”!
The alleged victim told her story to her parents who quickly took her to a doctor. Police were notified of the attack and a search began for the boys she accused of the crime. They were eventually stopped near Grayville early the next morning and arrested by State Police. Placed in the County Jail at Albion, the youths faced 3 counts of r**e charges. Newspaper articles said that relatives of the girl had to be restrained by police as the suspects were being jailed.
State’s Attorney Bamberth told the news media that the alleged victim had been examined by a doctor and he believed that she had indeed been r**ed. She was said to be in shock. As is the common practice in r**e cases, the girl’s name would not be revealed to the news media.
Gordon Gubbins, age 17 and from Albion, secured the services of attorneys Arnold and Boley of Olney to represent him in the defense of the charges. David Hollomon, age 18 and from Bellmont, was represented by court appointed attorney John Holland of Albion. Not guilty pleas were entered in Edwards County Circuit Court on January 9, 1952. Judge Crebs set April 14, 1952 as the date for the trial.
It was standing room only inside the Upstairs Courtroom when the trial began April 11, 1952. Everyone under the age of 21 except those called to testify was barred from the courtroom. The name of the alleged victim had been withheld up until now. However, it’s likely the name leaked out from various sources after the boys were arrested. Now given the requirement to face the defendants, the girl had to appear in court. Perhaps knowing for sure her identity was the reason many came to the trial. Newspapers never printed her name. Neither will her name be revealed in this article.
After questioning by attorneys for both sides, a jury of 6 men and 6 women was seated to decide the case. If Gubbins and Hollomon were found “guilty” they faced the possibility of life in prison with no possibility of parole. Edwards County State’s Attorney Peter Bamberth presented the case calling testimony from Dr. Paul Nierenberg who came back from New York to explain his findings in the examination of the girl. He backed up his previous statements that he believed the girl had been r**ed. Six other witnessed were called by the prosecution.
Now it was time for the defense team of Arnold and Boley to present their case. Their job was to discredit the prosecution’s case and perhaps the character of the alleged victim. Seven boys were called to testify in support of the characters of Gubbins and Hollomon. The defense lawyers attacked the evidence presented by the prosecution. It took a full week for all of the facts of the case to be presented in court.
Judge Crebs gave final instructions to the jury on April 18, 1952. They retired to the Jury Room for deliberations. Relatives and friends of the girl as well as the boys waited nervously outside the courtroom. What would be the verdict…guilty or innocent?
After 5 hours of deliberating, the Jury Foreman notified Judge Crebs that they had reached a verdict. Again the courtroom filled up quickly to hear the results of the trial. The jurors entered the Jury box and sat down. Judge Crebs asked, “Have you reached a decision?” The foreman replied, “We have, your Honor!” “So what say you? asked the Judge. To which the foreman replied, “We find the accused “not guilty”. The courtroom was filled with pandemonium as supporters of Gubbins and Hollomon celebrated with shouts of joy. Relatives and friends of the girl gasped and shouted “no” in disbelief. Gubbins and Hollomon were released from custody.
As one might expect, there was much debate for quite some time among Edwards County residents. Some thought the verdict was a disgrace while others thought it was just. It’s clear that only the 3 people involved in the case knew for sure if the jury got it right.
Gordon Gubbins moved to Dyer, Indiana and then to Conroe, Texas where he spent the rest of his life. He died August 7, 2014 at the age of 79 and was buried there. David Hollomon was killed in a 2-car crash February 28, 1956 on Route 130 north of Albion. He was 23 years old. His body is buried at Bethel Cemetery south of Bellmont.