07/14/2023
When my daughter was in kindergarten, she asked me “why is it OK to say someone is skinny but it’s not OK to say they are fat??” When I asked what prompted this question, she said that she heard two adults at school one compliment in the other on how skinny she was, and how happy the receiver of that compliment seemed.
I told her that some people think skinny bodies are better than bigger bodies. But that we should never treat someone different because of their size. It really struck me how much these young kids pick up on. Kids notice everything.
We recently saw someone we have not seen for a couple years and my son asked me in private “why they get fat??” I told him that he was right to notice the shift and that bodies change and thats ok. I did not rush in and say “don’t call her fat” because it’s the truth and it can be a neutral descriptor. I followed that up with “it’s not polite to comment on other peoples bodies without their permission.”
I just finished reading Virginia Saul Smith’s book Fat Talk: parenting in the age of diet culture. She breaks down fat phobia, and all the myriad of ways it shows up in our lives. She also read claims the word fat as a neutral descriptor. She emphasizes health at any weight, noting that a persons BMI is no indicator of health. She presents evidence why diet do not work. Any goal with the intent to lose weight is destined to fail, with the person gaining it back, and then some. (Healthy weight loss may come as a byproduct from other goals & behaviors, but that’s another topic!)
I did not agree with everything in this book. I’m still trying to process how much is my own internalized fear and conditioning around healthy vs. fat or how much is just my own opinion.
Have you read it?? Or even heard her speak on a podcast or something. What’s your take?