11/08/2025
A one-sided disappointing article from Psychology Today. I wrote a strongly worded letter…
Dear Editor Mariano,
I am a complex trauma treatment specialist and the author of You Don’t Need to Forgive: Trauma Recovery on Your Own Terms. I also advocate for trauma survivors experiencing family estrangement.
In your article, you wrote that some of the causes of estrangement are “Well beyond abuse and direct harm, young adults cite unmet emotional needs, violated boundaries, lack of emotional support,” implying that these reasons may be less valid than experiences of abuse or harm. However, they are equally valid. In my experience, many caregivers who fail to meet their adult children’s emotional needs, violate their boundaries, and are unable to offer emotional support have struggled with these same limitations throughout their parenting. As a result, many of their children have experienced developmental trauma and although they may not be currently physical or emotional abusive their continue to experience trauma responses that are very much in the present.
You also wrote that “estrangement is rarely a remedy.” I respectfully disagree. I have observed many clients make significant therapeutic progress during periods of family estrangement. Many trauma survivors have stated that they would never have felt safe enough to engage in trauma work without creating that distance. Some later chose to reconnect with their families, while others did not.
I am currently writing an evidence-based clinical book that supports family estrangement as a valid and, at times, necessary step in trauma recovery. This work aims to challenge the stigma surrounding estrangement and to give clinicians permission to support it when it aligns with their clients’ needs.
Please let me know if Psychology Today would be interested in publishing another perspective on this important topic.
Cut-offs cut deep and wide, their emotional impact reverberating far beyond the combatants. Because much of the suffering is hidden, repair is challenging for everyone, not least of all therapists.