09/19/2021
My post this Sunday will get into a controversial topic.
My daughter, Sunita sends me this podcast with the following remark, “I know you don’t listen to the podcasts I send you, but you should actually listen to this! Hosts are annoyingly liberal, but historically it’s pretty accurate.” Well, I did listen to this podcast! (Shh! Don’t tell her, but I actually listen to most of the podcasts she sends--Sunita is super smart and brings me a perspective that is quite different. After all, I don’t want to be in an echo chamber.)
Measures and definitions can hurt our feelings, but if the intent is to help us achieve better health (largely true) one should be more accepting of these. Bad health effects of severe obesity is not a figment of some racist insensitive imagination, but quite real affecting the longivity and quality of life. Are there pitfalls and shortcomings when these indices are applied across the board in a wide generalization without paying attention to race,/ethnicity, age, muscle mass/athleticism, etc.,? Absolutely, yes. Are there influences from insurance companies, Big Pharma, the military, and Big Healthcare in shaping policy that suits them? - most certainly. But, to throw away something like BMI (Body Mass Index) as a standardizing tool for measuring obesity and health is ill warranted. For example, scoring on standarized testing, such as the SAT or MCAT are generally good. However, they still have biases and are not perfect measures of selecting candidates for further education. We should strive to make these measures less biased and more rooted in science.
My mentor and professor (who is a native of India) used to jokingly say, “Indians are not made to eat and Mexicans are not made to drink, but both do plenty.” That statement would get him canceled in the current "woke" climate, but he was largely right. Brown people have a tremendous risk of metabolic syndrome - which is a complex of truncal or abdominal obesity, hyperlipidemia (high triglycerides or fats in the blood), fatty liver and diabetes mellitus. Just because it offends us as a race, we should not ignore the higher risks posed by our genetics. The Pima people are held out as a bad example for metabolic syndrome. While the Pimas in Arizona have all these health problems, the Pimas living in the Sierra Madre mountains in Mexico are fit as a fiddle and are very healthy! Even though they have the same “bad” genes, they eat healthy foods and are very active. So, yes, we can overcome our genetic shortcomings by controlling our environment.
So, here is that podcast. Yes, it is “historically” correct, but it cherry picks the exceptions and in my view overstates the case for racism and sexism.
Show Maintenance Phase, Ep The Body Mass Index - Aug 3, 2021