10/16/2024
👉In this day and age, everyone's an expert, but few people actually know anything.
::::
The below screenshot is from another group I am a member of.
For context, this group has over 100K members, with 20 moderators all with advanced degrees in exercise related fields.
This question is in regards to a program this person bought.
::::
I had no idea that Sheriff's had advanced training in exercise technique and coaching.
::::
OPINIONS are a valid form of science, when those opinions are backed by large numbers.
This is referred to as "observational science".
---
"I have seen over 100 different species of birds flying over my head, that must mean all birds can fly."
---
👆Great example of observational science.
We know it's not right, there are some birds that don't fly, but based on observing a large sample of birds, this would be a reasonable opinion to take.
----
In fact before we had "peer reviewed" journals Doctors did most of their Doctoring off opinions based on what they experienced.
----
People LOVE to give out health and exercise advice.
Especially if those people "solved a problem".
👇
Like - "every time I deadlift I hurt my back, so ill stop deadlifting."
Bam - no more lower back pain.
🤬
🤬That must mean the deadlift is an exercise that causes and promotes lower back pain.
🤬
Maybe that just means you don't know how to deadlift?
----
"I lost 30 lbs by eating Keto. Therefore everyone must eat Keto to lose weight."
👉Maybe...but probably not.
🤷♂️Maybe that just means you needed some kind of diet to follow that imposed some restriction instead of the diet you were following which was...
🤷♂️..."put food in my mouth."
----
So the next time someone gives you advice that is NOT in the field of that advice (i.e. your mechanic giving you plumbing advice, or your Doctor giving you exercise advice) ask them two questions:
🙋♀️"Why?"
🧐"How many times have you seen this happen?"
----
If they can't tell you WHY - as in "Why do deadlifts cause lower back pain"...they are working off a weak understanding of what they are talking about.
---
If they answer the 2nd question with "just me" or something that essentially corresponds to an incredibly low number....they are working off their own limited observations.
Not wrong, but should not be taken as "gospel".
---
If on the other hand they reply with an actual reason like "deadlifts create a lot of shear at the lumbar spine which often exaggerates pre-existing lower back issues."
True statement.
And/or "I have seen this happen dozens of times before"
They probably have a good understanding of what they are talking about.