08/30/2024
A note today:
Chinese medicine and its practitioners regularly receive denigration, disbelief, and dismissal from those who are steeped in Western biomedical traditions, arguing fervently that acupuncture and Chinese medicine as a whole are pseudoscience. Let’s be clear: for something to be deemed “scientific”, it has to have been filtered through a paradigm that is indigenous primarily to Europe and the United States. Eastern medical traditions are blatantly considered unscientific because they have not stemmed from the conventional biomedical traditions, but this hardly disqualifies them from having profound wisdom and significant efficacy. As I’ve been diving into this text on Shen-Hammer pulse diagnosis, I am taken aback at its sophistication and its cultivation of subtle diagnostic skill. Spoken another way, I am abhorred by the Western scientific and specifically, the biomedical outright rejection of Chinese medicine and its comprehensive, sophisticated and subtle diagnostic process, which aims to understand the absolutely necessity of relationship among parts of a whole. Just because Western medicine refuses to acknowledge worldviews beyond its own, just because it refuses to slow down, and to take in more subtle expressions of the human body, just because it suffers from a case of Modern Human Supremacy—believing that its perspective is the sole reality—does not translate to the complete denigration of a whole medicine. In fact, it only reveals its own myopathy, and fails to consider how much the proof is in the pudding. So many modern ailments are wildly misunderstood and not adequately treated, and this failure is evidenced to the degree that people do not understand the nature of their lives or their suffering. If the Western medical paradigm opted to take seriously the sophisticated techniques of a deeply rooted medicine stemming from a non-western paradigm, dedicating time and intellectual power and will towards understanding that paradigm, they may be less arrogant as to blindly refer to these methods as pseudoscience and superstition. The capacity to learn these techniques is extremely difficult and requires an incredible amount of skill to master