04/12/2022
This is why we speak up. If you want to see the system change to support true informed consent in pregnancy/ birth, then welcome to the club! 👇
Repost:
It is easy to turn practitioners into the villains of the birth world (and yes, there are some who are), but many of them are at the mercy of a paternalistic, litigation-driven system that ties their hands. If they have a desire to provide truly evidence-based care (and yes, there are some who do) that happens to go against hospital or birthplace policy, they are at real risk of having disciplinary action taken against their license, losing privileges at a given birthplace, or even losing their license and livelihood altogether. They practice from a place of fear, so their care, in turn, is often fear-driven and fear-based.
I think it’s fair to say that the current state of the maternity system is a reflection of the current state of society. Fear-based practice or fear-based governance both yield the same result: limiting choices and restricting freedoms in an effort to maintain control while still presenting the illusion of consent. The self-protective mantra of these systems becomes “the fewer choices they have, the less risk we have.” In birth, women are told they have choices and are presented with a distorted version of consent and “shared decision making” as long as it conforms to the system’s acceptable levels of risk and benefit. If it doesn’t, then the default is to hide behind the seemingly-altruistic shield of safety.
“I want to have my twins at home.”
“You can’t, it isn’t safe.”
“I want to have a vaginal breech birth.”
“You can’t, it isn’t safe.”
“I want to have a vaginal birth, even though I’ve had X number of cesareans.”
“You can’t, it isn’t safe.”
And so the mainstream medical model continues to contract in on itself, limiting mothers’ choices, limiting midwifery scope, limiting practitioner skill, all in the name of risk reduction masquerading solely as safety. If we don’t let them do it, it can’t hurt us. If we don’t let them learn it, soon it won’t even be an option.
Here’s the only safe bet I know: the current system is so infused and infected with fear that any number of alterations, exceptions, policies, procedures, laws…any attempt to “fix” it is futile. It is unrecognizable as a safe space for true physiological birth. That safe space is a space entirely separate, one that, with enough outcry, can become the new way to birth.
A new way and a return to the old way. A way built on trust, autonomy, and freedom. This is the way I want. If you want it too, don’t stay silent any longer.