The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

Home
United States
Lafayette, IN
The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

I don’t promise perfection, but I promise you DELICIOUS and beautifully decorated sugar cookies!

11/04/2025

Can’t believe it’s been 2 years already! This little home business has kept me very busy. Thank you so much for the support - I appreciate each and every one of you!
😘😘

November is already almost completely booked - and December is already starting to fill up! If you need cookies for the holidays, don’t delay REACH OUT SOON!

11/03/2025

Check out these beauties created for a recent baby shower. The colors turned out so lovely!

11/02/2025

I’m a week late posting, but happy 80th anniversary to University Lutheran Church in West Lafayette!

11/01/2025

I LOVE THESE! Realistic pizza slice cookies for the staff members of our local Little Caesars!

I can print PRACTICALLY ANYTHING on a cookie! Even other food items 😂

10/31/2025

Pickleball cookies for all my new favorite ladies on our last league night! So much fun - can’t wait to do it all again in the spring!

10/30/2025

A very happy 1st birthday to sweet Enisa!

10/22/2025

Not Perfect Halloween offerings!

Orders must be received by Saturday, October 25 and all invoices must be paid by 11:59pm on Sunday, October 26. Orders will be available for pickup on either Wednesday 10/29 from 3:00-7:00pm OR Thursday 10/30 from 9:00am-2:00pm. All cookies will be vanilla-almond flavored (allergy alerts for wheat, eggs, dairy, and tree nuts).

What I’ve got…
• 3-pack Hocus Pocus witches cookies - $12
• 3-pack spooky Purdue cookies - $12
• 2-pack “6-7” ghost cookies - $8

Please PM me to order. Include what you’d like, your name and email address, and your preferred pick up date and time (see above for options).

Thank you for supporting my small business!
🎃👻💀

10/21/2025

Pricing updates - prices on ingredients have continued to rise, so I had to make the hard decision to adjust my prices a bit. Full pricing details are available on my website.

Also, to maximize my time and efficiency, I have implemented a 2 dozen minimum for all hand-decorated cookies.

If you’ve previously reached out to me about an order and I’ve already given you a price quote based on my old prices, those will still be honored!

Thank you so much for your continued support of my small business 😘😘

10/20/2025

More beautiful bridal shower cookies! I loved the look of the Halloween ones from earlier in the week, so I used some of the same design concepts on this set. I hope Maddie had the best shower!

10/17/2025

Haley found her boo! Congrats to the happy couple getting hitched this weekend! Her sister ordered these for her bridal shower held earlier this week. They are definitely in my TOP 5 FAVORITE cookies I’ve made to date - SO CUTE!!

10/12/2025

BEETLEJUICE COOKIES!! I made too many and have lots of leftovers from this weekend’s sales at production of Beetlejuice Jr.

I’d love to sell these off at bargain prices!

• Five pack of cookies (one of each design) - SOLD OUT
• Single Lydia cookie - $2 (8 AVAILABLE)
• Single Adam cookie - $2 (8 AVAILABLE)
• Single Barbara cookie - $2 (2 AVAILABLE)
• Single logo cookie - $2 (2 AVAILABLE)

Message me to claim!

These cookies freeze great, so stock up 😉😉

10/11/2025

Check out these beauties I made for a recent baptism!

Address

Cedar Lane
Lafayette, IN
47905

Telephone

+17655862848

Website

http://thenotperfectcookieco.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Not Perfect Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Practice

Send a message to The Not Perfect Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Want your practice to be the top-listed Clinic in Lafayette?