The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

Home
United States
Lafayette, IN
The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

I don’t promise perfection, but I promise you DELICIOUS and beautifully decorated sugar cookies!

03/20/2026

Easter Cookies! Bringing back some classics from Easter ‘24 🐣 They make the perfect Easter basket stuffers!

Order by DM by Friday, March 27. Invoices will be sent out via email on March 28 and must be paid by 11:59pm on March 29. All orders MUST be picked up on Thursday, April 2 (between 9am-2pm or 4pm-8pm). Thanks for supporting my small business ❤️

Personalized Bunny Cookie - $5.00 each
Bunny Face on a Stick - $5.00 each
4 Packs “Peeps” Cookies (boxed set) - $8.00 each

03/08/2026

I love a unique cookie request! My client’s cat had eye-removal surgery and she wanted to thank the amazing veterinary staff for their hard work and talents. These turned out so cute!

02/26/2026

Jack’s First Rodeo! Happy 1st birthday little guy - I love these special cookies!!

02/24/2026

Another first birthday - and another new theme to me! ONE FOR THE BOOKS!

I just love how these turned out. They were certainly challenging, but very fun to make.

02/16/2026

Join me at a class sometime!

02/14/2026

Happy Valentine’s Day cookie lovers! I’m on vacation so no new V-Day pics to share, but how cute are these bourbon-themed birthday cookies?!?!

02/12/2026

The ovens at The Not Perfect Cookie Co. are OFF until my return on Sunday afternoon. If you message me and I don’t get back with you, it’s because my sister and I will be enjoying the MOST EPIC elder millennial weekend in Las Vegas! See you later 😘😘

02/11/2026

BUCKET LIST ALERT - Parks & Recreation is one of my all-time favorite shows. And since I also work for an Indiana parks department, it’s extra special to me. AND, fun fact - I was actually contacted by the props master before they started filming, so I feel like I helped make the Pawnee Parks office look legit. Also, I take credit for the Duke Silver storyline… I can tell you more if you want - DM me.

Anyway, my amazing coworker requested these cookies for a special Galentine’s gathering with her besties, and I had SO MUCH FUN making them. I love them!

❤️

02/10/2026

I made a few extras!! There are 2 sets available (a bow can be added to make the bear more girly!) - $12 each

DM to claim!

02/07/2026

The cutest gender reveal cookies! Bows or Arrows??

I just heard back from them… it’s a GIRL!! Lots of bows coming their way! Congrats to the parents-to-be!

02/04/2026

Lots of 1st birthdays recently… here’s another cute cookie set! Happy birthday little guy!

02/03/2026

One Silly Goose - what an adorable theme for a first birthday!

Address

Cedar Lane
Lafayette, IN
47905

Telephone

+17655862848

Website

http://thenotperfectcookieco.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Not Perfect Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Practice

Send a message to The Not Perfect Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Want your practice to be the top-listed Clinic in Lafayette?