The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

02/03/2026

One Silly Goose - what an adorable theme for a first birthday!

02/01/2026

Happy birthday to a Spider-Man loving 3 year old!!

02/01/2026

Who needs a fun and delicious cookie tray for your Super Bowl party next weekend?!?!

Three options available:
• Mixed platter with opposing helmets cookies
• Patriots fan platter with one helmet and one logo cookie
• Seahawks fan platter with one helmet and one logo cookie

Each platter includes 12 wedge cookies, 4 footballs, a Super Bowl cookie, and the 2 other cookies of your choice (depending on platter chosen - see above).

Cost is $50/platter. Pick up in Lafayette, Indiana on Saturday evening 6-8pm or Sunday 10am-2pm. DM me to order by Tuesday 2/3. All invoices must be paid by Thursday 2/5.

01/29/2026

New teenager Peyton threw a spa-themed party and I got to make treats! I hope she had the best day. Happy birthday Peyton!

01/28/2026

Who’s joining me for a “Love is in the Air” cookie decorating class?!?!

Limited spots left for our special Valentine’s Cookie Decorating Class, hosted by The Not Perfect Cookie Co. at McAllister Rec Center! 🩷🍪

Grab your loved ones🩷- friends, family, or significant others, and learn how to decorate Valentine-themed cookies! To make your life easier, we will provide you all with all the materials you will need!

📲Register while you still can at our website at https://secure.rec1.com/IN/lafayette-parks-recreation-in/catalog or call McAllister Rec Center at (765) 807-1360

01/25/2026

Not Perfect Valentine’s Day options!! I’d love to create a sweet treat for you and your loved ones!

Orders due by Saturday, February 7, and all cookie orders must be picked up on Wednesday, February 11.

Link to the online order form is in the comments. Thanks for supporting my small business ❤️❤️

01/23/2026

Have there ever been more DELICIOUS cookies?!?!

Made these for a friend, and man was she happy 😜😍

01/20/2026

I have ALL the feelings today, so nostalgia had me digging into my photos from my IU days. And I found this gem!! I decorated this cookie at Christmas 2003, depicting my dear friend Aaron () in his Student Athletic Board red coat. Who would have thought I’d make a career out of cookie decorating based on this “art”?? 😂😂

01/19/2026

TODAY IS THE DAY!! The day all Hoosier fans have always hoped and wished for, but let’s be honest… never thought would ACTUALLY happen. But, today our Hoosiers battle for a national championship! In football!! I’m both overly excited and nervous for tonight. Bring on the Hurricanes! GO HOOSIERS!! ❤️🤍❤️🤍

🏈

01/18/2026

Today we celebrate my nephew’s “rookie year”! How is he 1 already?!?! Happy birthday little man - we love you!

⚾️

01/13/2026

Happy 3rd (Year) Down to Salvador! I hope he had the best 3rd birthday ever.

01/13/2026

Last day to order!! You get 12 unique cookies (no repeats!!) for $45/dozen - a set like this would normally cost $65+!

GO HOOSIERS!! ❤️🤍❤️🤍