12/12/2025
‼️WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT THIS‼️
As doulas, we go into MANY hospitals.🏥
Recently, after a provider was caught in malpractice via video, we noticed these signs got plastered up EVERYWHERE 😠
The new policy is that no videos during a birth are allowed. No pictures during pushing are allowed. No medical staff can be in any media and it is up to the doctor’s discretion whether any photos will be permitted at all.
BUT HERE IS THE KICKER…
I personally called and asked to present this policy, BUT IT IS NOT WRITTEN and they stated that they do not have to present a policy WITHOUT A COURT ORDER…um…what?!
This is problematic on MANY levels.
1. If you have been watching TikTok/Instagram recently, there are hundreds of videos going up of women being mistreated during their birth. Having no photos/videos allowed, ultimately would not have provided these women with evidence that they later used in a court of law to seek justice.
2. I have many clients who want birth photography, and with the amount of hospitals that are beginning to implement this policy, there might be many clients who arrive to their birth, realizing that they can no longer capture this transformative moment. A service that they paid for in advance, may no longer be available at a moments notice.
3. Many of my clients want videos as tokens to remember their birth, this is no longer something I can guarantee, as non-compliance with hospital policy, even if those policies aren’t presented)
4. And here’s what most people don’t realize: Michigan is a one-party consent state. This means you are legally allowed to record audio or video as long as one person in the conversation (you) consents. Hospital staff do not have to consent for you to record your own medical care.🤳
5. Having it be up to the doctors discretion creates a hierarchy of power within the birth space, needing to ask permission to take a picture of you and your own baby. 😤
So why would a hospital suddenly try to implement a blanket “no video, no photos, no documentation whatsoever” rule—especially when the law doesn’t support that level of control? I really cant say, but here’s what I do know…
➡️ If your hospital is scrambling to shut down all recording, you should immediately ask yourself why.🤨
➡️ If your hospital refuses to show you a written policy, that’s a massive red flag.🚩
➡️ If your hospital “doesn’t allow video,” you should be deeply concerned, because truly evidence-based, patient-centered care has nothing to hide. (Ask any midwife or OB who practices evidence based care, they will always say they have nothing to hide)🫣
Evidence-based hospitals welcome transparency.
Evidence-based hospitals empower families.
Evidence-based hospitals don’t fear documentation—they use it to improve outcomes.
If your birth space suddenly becomes a place where cameras are banned, questions aren’t answered, and policies “exist” but can’t be shown…
you deserve to stop and say:
“What are they trying to protect—me, or themselves?”
Birth is your medical care.
Birth is your story.
And you deserve to document it.
(To add nuance, one argument has been that this policy protects other patient’s privacy, and helps to enforce HIPAA laws. However, if you are in a birth suite and not sharing it with another patient, other patient’s information should not be in your room, and while you’re pushing a baby out, you are likely not exposing or risking another patient’s privacy)
Please share this to help spread awareness over this issue