02/03/2026
Hey there everyone!! Itās Rochelle here and Iām about to hop up on my soapbox!
Jeri shared a clip with me earlier that was very disturbing. The clip showed Dr. Oz promoting The Rural Health Transformation Fund, which provides federal funding for each state and has special focus on those of us living in rural America who need access to mental health care. I am in agreement that we DO need more funding for rural mental health care.
However, this particular funding would be used to provide a mode of mental health care that would utilize AI chatbots or avatars over utilizing real, human therapists in rural areas. He appears to be using the guise of āif we do it right, weāll be building a more sustainable healthcare systemā.
Ozās statement on receiving mental healthcare in rural areas:
āThere's no question about it, whether you want it or not -- the best way to help some of these communities is gonna be AI-based avatars.ā
⨠Let me clear my throat āØ
There will never be a chat bot, an avatar, or any other AI generated āpersonā better equipped to treat human mental health conditions than another human. Ever.
Can using ChatGPT be beneficial for some who are gathering info about a mental health condition and its most effective treatment? Absolutely.
While AI is useful for immediate, low-stakes psychoeducation or habit-tracking, it cannot replace the nuanced relational work of a qualified human professional therapist. Please.
Human therapists are more effective than AI because they provide genuine empathy, clinical judgment, and a therapeutic alliance built on trust, which are essential for treating deep-seated emotional issues.
While AI offers immediate, standardized, and accessible support, it lacks human understanding, cannot interpret nonverbal cues, and risks providing dangerous advice in crisis situations.
Other concerns I have include the following:
Emotional Depth vs. Simulation: Human therapists provide authentic compassion and can "hold space" for emotions, whereas AI merely simulates empathy through algorithms.
Contextual and Clinical Judgment: Therapists understand complex life contexts, can tailor treatment approaches, and know when to challenge or support a patient, a skill AI lacks.
The Therapeutic Alliance: The relationship between therapist and clientābased on trust, nonverbal cues, and shared human experienceāis the most critical driver of successful therapy, which AI cannot replicate.
Handling Crisis and Risk: Human professionals are trained to manage high-risk scenarios, such as suicidal ideation, whereas AI chatbots have demonstrated potential to provide harmful, dangerous, or stigmatizing responses.
Nuanced Communication: Human therapy involves reading body language, tone, and silences, allowing for a deeper exploration of trauma, unlike AI which relies on textual input.
Ethical and Regulatory Standards: Licensed therapists adhere to strict ethical guidelines regarding privacy and care, while AI operates within automated parameters.
((Did I use Google to identify the top concerns about using AI as therapy? You bet I did! However, these are legitimate concerns I would hope most therapists and clients would have!))
Please, if you are in need of mental health care, reach out to us. We can provide a consult to ensure that you are placed with a human therapist that can best suit your individual mental health needs. Donāt give up on your own autonomy and critical thinking skills.
If Jeri or I arenāt a good fit, we would love to provide you with a referral to another clinician in our area that could better serve your specific needs.
Please do not lose touch with human connection in a world that continues to divide us with rhetoric and propaganda We have to continue to show up as human to human.