07/13/2022
Are we sliding into the vicious circle of insufficient sleep?
Yesterday I got lost on the way from Greece to Bosnia, got to my Airbnb much later than I was supposed to, and went to bed several hours later. Today, I woke up after roughly 5 hours of sleep, and my usual beautiful morning sense of feeling rested, refreshed, and looking forward to the day was no longer there.
Instead, I felt tired and did not want to open my eyes. The usual sense of lightness of being was replaced with heaviness and unpleasant sensations in my chest.
I felt slightly irritated for no good reason. And all the projects I planned for today felt like a drag. I immediately started thinking about how I could devise an excuse to extricate myself from doing them.
While we have different sensitivity to the effects of sleep restriction, the story I just shared is ubiquitous. We have many reasons to go to bed and wake up earlier. Sometimes we need to finish up work or help kids with their homework, or after putting kids to bed, we finally can have a few hours to ourselves;
No matter the reason, most people in our society do not get enough sleep daily. And insufficient sleep launches vicious circles. The following day, we may feel hungrier and eat more, or feel more irritated and snap at a loved one. Or we may feel less energy, less motivation to get up and do things, or more depressed or anxious.
We may get more coffee or other energy drinks to wake up and become fully functional. Closer to the evening, we may finally feel a surge of energy, and we get more and more active; we want to do all those things we did not want to do in the morning, so we plunge into action while the clock keeps ticking: 8 pm, 9 pm, 11 pm, and we keep working being oblivious to the time.
We end up going to bed later, and the following morning the story repeats itself: feeling like we don't want to wake up, feeling tired, irritated, needing more time and coffee to wake up.
This vicious circle is familiar to most people, but we tend to notice the immediate short-term effects of this vicious circle.
Today, I offer to look at this vicious circle from a different perspective and inquire if this vicious circle has hidden adverse effects on various systems of the organism. And if the vicious circle may have long-term consequences.
In one of the previous posts, we looked at the detrimental effect of reduced sleep duration to four hours a night on glucose regulation.
Does the result of this study apply to everyday life? Well, it certainly does apply to people who sleep for 4 hours a night and informs us about detrimental consequences.
However, sleeping for 4 hours a night is very difficult to tolerate for most people for more than a couple of days. And most people who chronically are not getting enough sleep report sleeping 5-6 hours a night.
It could be that 5-6 hours of sleep is sufficient to avoid the negative effect on glucose regulation we observed when people sleep for 4 hours a night.
Before we look at what science can tell us, I would like to bring our attention to two subtle processes in most people's lives sleeping for 5-6 hours a night.
Some of them are software engineers, and others are physicians, psychotherapists, and scientists. They are professionals who spend 8-10 hours either sitting in the office or driving, have low physical activity during the day and have access to plentiful snacks and food throughout the day.
A sedentary lifestyle and unlimited access to food are two markers of a so-called western lifestyle. These markers are also some of the most critical risk factors for developing type 2 diabetes.
From a practical perspective, we can ask if restricting sleep to 5 hours a night throughout the weekdays combined with food availability and a sedentary lifestyle would affect glucose regulation and insulin sensitivity.
Below, I will explore two recent research studies that attempted to shed some light on this question.
The first study recruited 16 healthy young women and men (average age 22) with an average habitual sleep duration of 8.5 hours.
In the first period of the study, subjects had three days of plentiful sleep (9 hours per night) to minimize any effect of potential sleep restriction before the start of the study. During these three days, they consumed an energy-balanced diet (i.e., they were not allowed to overeat).
In the second period of the study, sleep duration was restricted from 9 hours to 5 hours a night for the next five nights to stimulate a 5-day work week.
Finally, in the third period, which also lasted five nights, people once again enjoyed 9 hours per night of sleep. During both second and third 5-day periods, they could eat as much as they wanted to.
Results showed that sleep restriction to 5 hours a night for five nights in healthy men and women led to a 20% reduction in insulin sensitivity and compensatory increased insulin response to glucose.
This compensatory increase in insulin response to glucose is the body's attempt to adapt and maintain normal blood sugar levels.
Moreover, when people slept for 5 hours, they consumed much more food. In future posts, we will explore how insufficient sleep alters our appetite and promotes weight gain.
To summarize, this study showed that when we take people who need 8-9 hours of sleep and ask them to sleep for 5 hours, they start developing insulin resistance.
Why do we care about insulin resistance?
Higher insulin resistance is a risk factor for developing diabetes Mellitus and accelerated aging of the metabolic system.
And now, let's see how well the study design parallels the real life of those of us who are getting 5-6 hours of sleep.
First, strictly speaking, the study design did not mimic the real-life situation of most people who get insufficient sleep. Most people sleeping for 5-6 hours do this not just for one week but chronically over many years.
Theoretically, physiology may adapt to chronic sleep restriction without adverse health consequences. In future articles, we will look at the likelihood of this possibility by considering long-term observational studies. As a preview, I will mention that the long-term studies show that people chronically restricting their sleep to 5-6 hours suffer from a higher risk of diabetes and other diseases.
Another factor limiting the applicability of the above study is that recruited subjects were young (average age of 22 years old) and healthy. How would this apply to middle-aged people who are no longer as healthy as 20-year-olds and who might be sleeping a bit longer, for example, 5.5-6 hours during the workweek?
Let's look at the second study.
Here is what this study did:
๐ธ It replaced young men and women with middle-aged men and women. I should mention that according to other research studies, people in their 40-50s have the shortest self-reported sleep.
๐ธ In the sleep-restricted condition, people slept for 5.5 hours instead of 5 hours.
๐ธ While in the previous study, sleep restriction lasted for five days, in the current study, the period of sleep restriction lasted 14 days.
๐ธ Following a typical western lifestyle, subjects in the study led a sedentary lifestyle and had access to plentiful food typical to many middle-aged professionals.
This study again showed that reducing sleep duration to 5.5 hours reduced insulin sensitivity and glucose tolerance at the end of a 14-day sleep-restricted condition.
The authors put it very nicely: "when part of a Western-like lifestyle, recurrent sleep restriction can result in reduced insulin sensitivity."
What we learned in this article about the effect of sleep restriction is just the tip of the iceberg. In the future posts, we will learn about:
๐ธ What do observational studies tell us about the effects of chronically restricted sleep duration that last not just 14 days but months and years?
๐ธ Does insufficient sleep make us hungrier?
๐ธ Does insufficient sleep lead to weight gain?
๐ธ What other bodily systems insufficient sleep harms?
And, of course, sleep duration is not the only important factor and is not the most critical factor. Sleep quality significantly impacts metabolic health and most other aspects of our health, and we will soon start learning about sleep quality!
Note: This publication is part of educational series: "Myths About Sleep, Insomnia, Health, And Disease That Cause Disease & Shorten Life."
If you would like to get future articles from the series (Free of Charge) delivered to your email inbox, you are welcome to provide your email via the link: https://www.thebooststrategy.com/sleep-insomnia-myths
References:
Eckel RH, Depner CM, Perreault L, Markwald RR, Smith MR, McHill AW, et al. Morning circadian misalignment during short sleep duration impacts insulin sensitivity. Curr Biol 2015;25(22):3004e10.
Nedeltcheva, A.V., Kessler, L., Imperial, J. and Penev, P.D., 2009. Exposure to recurrent sleep restriction in the setting of high caloric intake and physical inactivity results in increased insulin resistance and reduced glucose tolerance. The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, 94(9), pp.3242-3250.
Horne J 2008 Short sleep is a questionable risk factor for obesity and related disorders: statistical versus clinical significance. Biol Psychol 77:266โ276
Kripke DF, Garfinkel L, Wingard DL, Klauber MR, Marler MR 2002 Mortality associated with sleep duration and insomnia. Arch Gen Psychiatry 59:131โ136
Basner M, FombersteinKM,Razavi FM, Banks S, William JH, Rosa RR, Dinges DF 2007 American time use survey: sleep time and its relationship to waking activities. Sleep 30:1085โ1095
Yaggi HK, Araujo AB, McKinlay JB 2006 Sleep duration as a risk factor for the development of type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Care 29: 657โ661
Gangwisch JE, Heymsfield SB, Boden-Albala B, Buijs RM, Kreier F, Pickering TG, Rundle AG, Zammit GK, Malaspina D 2007 Sleep duration as a risk factor for diabetes incidence in a large U.S. sample. Sleep 30:1667โ1673
Discover results of cutting-edge scientific research you will not find anywhere else ... Sleep and Insomnia Myth that Cause Disease & Shorten Life