
07/29/2025
🔬 Does Having A Enhance Outcomes Associated with ?
A new 2025 RCT by Gavanda et al. compared the outcomes of supervised (in-person), app-guided, and self-directed (PDF) resistance training over 10 weeks in trained men and women (n = 79). Each group performed the same full-body training program 3x/week, differing only in the level of guidance and feedback.
📈 Key Findings:
Supervised training (SUP) led to the greatest gains in squat strength (+26.6 kg), fat-free mass (+1.4 kg), and well-being (+15.7 pts on WHO-5).
All groups improved bench press 1RM, but only the supervised group showed significantly superior squat improvements—highlighting the value of real-time technical feedback in complex, multi-joint lifts.
Adherence rates were highest in SUP (88%), compared to APP (81%) and PDF (52%).
Supervision satisfaction (S-SRQ) was also significantly higher in SUP vs APP.
Fat mass increased slightly in the APP group, possibly due to lack of nutritional control and/or compensatory eating.
💡 Implications:
Direct supervision from a enhances , neuromuscular adaptations, psychological well-being, and accountability—especially in technically demanding exercises. While app-based training showed promise for accessibility and moderate gains, it lacked the effectiveness of live coaching - which can be attributed to possibly many reasons, but most likely you want to be a beast in person and not embarass yourself. That’s motivation enough.
📱 Realistically, hybrid models combining digital platforms with periodic human feedback may offer scalable alternatives where consistent in-person coaching is not feasible. Thoughts?
📚 Source: Gavanda et al., J Strength Cond Res, 2025.