04/29/2026
Question: Should I pop a stye on my eye?
Dr. Po**ck responds: Generally speaking, no.
The layman's term 'stye' is usually more than a single type of lesion. In medical parlance, a stye is known as a hordeolum. To make things more complicated, there are internal hordeola (plural for hordeolum) and external hordeola.
External vs Internal Hordeolum
The external hordeolum is what most people think of a stye. It is a blocked, sometimes inflamed, sometimes painful oil gland on the outside of the lid margin. Often it is associated with an eye lash. Causes are many but are ultimately related to something irritating the gland to the point where the opening swells shut and the contents produced have nowhere to go. They're more common in children because they rub their eyes more and often with dirty hands. But some adults never seem to outgrow them. Treatment: warm compresses - as warm as tolerable and as often as possible.
An internal hordeolum is the same process as above but involving the larger meibomian oil glands which are located deeper in the lid. These can get quite large and can become quite painful. In most cases the natural course is similar to the external hordeolum: warm compresses do the trick and it will either shrink gradually or come to a head and open and drain spontaneously. Massaging with the fingertips following the warm compresses can encourage the process.
In most cases, neither of these is a true 'infection' (although they can lead to one - see below) so it is best to let Mother Nature heal things. Most over-the-counter preparations do little and antibiotic drops or ointment cannot really pe*****te inside the gland so are a waste of money.
To Pop or Not to Pop
When either of these lesions is acutely inflamed - but more so the internal hordeolum - there is always the chance that this is the early stage of a more serious problem, namely an infection. In this case, popping the 'stye' yourself runs the risk of actually spreading the infection to other glands that weren't involved or other parts of the lid. This is known as a preseptal cellulitis and has to be treated with antibiotic pills.
Worse yet, if the infection spreads from there into the deeper tissues behind the eyelid, this is known as an orbital cellulitis and constitutes a medical emergency. Untreated, especially in children, the infection can threaten the vision.
In some situations, the hordeolum has come to a head and is either 'pointing' on the outside of the lid where it is readily visible or on the underside of the lid. The eye doctor may opt to pick the top off with a sterile needle to relieve the pressure and allow the heat and massage to release the contents. But this is done under a microscope to be certain other structures are not being disturbed.
Chalazion
After the acute phase of the hordeolum has passes, often what will be left is a chalazion, a hard nodule that can be felt or even seen if it is large enough. There is no tenderness but it can be aggravating and in rare cases can actually cause slight blurring. The chalazion can be treated with an I&D (incision and drainage) minor surgery procedure: the lid is numbed, a chalazion clamp is placed on the lid and the lid is flipped over or everted, a sharp scalpel is used to perform a small incision and usually the contents - lipogranulomatous material - pop out easily, but sometimes needs a little help, the eye is pressure-patched for a couple of hours and antibiotic ointment is prescribed for several days.
Beware of Chronic 'Styes'
Lastly, if you have a 'stye' that is not getting better or that has been present for more than a few weeks, it is important to have it checked by an eye doctor. In rare cases, what looks like a simple stye may actually be a serious condition known as sebaceous cell carcinoma, a rare but potentially deadly cancer that can masquerade as a number of benign-looking but chronic lid lesions.
This answer is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Schedule a consult with Ocala Eye at (352) 290-7180 if you are experiencing an eye issue as described above.