02/13/2026
There is so much disconnect over the use of whips within clicker training. Maybe it would help to clarify things. Let's call an apple an apple.
"Whip" - a stick like object that is used as an aversive for the horse to work to relieve. No matter how gently the aversive is applied (a tickle, gentle tapping, a little flick).
"Target" - an object or visible object on a stick that the horse seeks out and touches with their nose or other body part in order to earn positive reinforcement.
"Fly swatter" - a stick with some tassles at the end for removing flies from the horse, visibly distinguishable from a whip
"Scratcher" - a stick with curved nubs at the end for scratching the horse. Also visibly distinguishable from a whip.
Whips are a tool, they can be used gently or harshly, they can be whatever you condition them to be. But why condition a the wrong tool? If you're using a whip as a target, a fly swatter or a scratcher, just use a target, a swatter or a scratcher.
Why? Because it matters to the humans. Whips have been conditioned to humans for thousands of years (like from BCE times and before) as tools of force, violence, and oppression. Why continue to use these when there are more appropriate equivalents? Without mixed meaning.
For fun i looked up the dictionary definition of a whip
Merriam-Webster
"To strike with a slender lithe implement (such as a lash or rod) especially as a punishment"
"an instrument consisting usually of a handle and lash forming a flexible rod that is used for whipping"
American heritage dictionary
"An instrument, either a flexible rod or a flexible thong or lash attached to a handle, used for driving animals or administering corporal punishment"
" To strike with a strap or rod; lash: whipped the horse with the reins."
These are the definitions of the noun and verb "whip".
Use the term and tool that fits the definition you are using it as. Using the terms correctly, that alone would clear up sooo much miscommunications and misunderstandings. If you're using a whip, its a whip. If its a target, its a target. And so on.