12/23/2021
Mental Health in Media: Post 22
Ebenezer Scrooge from A Christmas Carol (any version and book)
Topic: Generosity and Gratitude
🎵“...And the worst of the worst
The most hated and cursed
Is the one that we call Scrooge.
Unkind as any
And the wrath of many
This is Ebenezer Scrooge…”🎵
(Scrooge, The Muppets, Muppet Christmas Carol)
Ebenezer Scrooge, the classic, greedy miser of Western literature and film, is also a great example of the ability to change, generosity, and the three-step recovery model in counseling.
Most of my familiarity with A Christmas Carol comes from the book by Charles Dickens, Mickey’s Christmas Carol (1983), A Christmas Carol (1984, with George C. Scott), The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992), and A Christmas Carol (1999, with Sir Patrick Stewart). What version is your favorite? Do you have a go-to for the holidays?
In all versions of the story, the theme of change and generosity (and the counseling model) are very much present. Scrooge goes from someone who would rather see poor people die to “decrease the surplus population” to donating large sums to charity and taking a more active interest in his family, friends, and acquaintances.
Generosity is important for countless social, community-building reasons, but did you know it is also important to our own mental health? Giving to others can reduce stress (and blood pressure), lower depression, and even help you live longer. We tend to feel better about ourselves too. And who doesn’t love that?
The great thing about showing generosity is it doesn’t have to be in large sums of money, or any money at all. You could donate your time and service. You could say a kind word to someone and express gratitude. You can also accept generosity and gratitude from others. Giving a little of whatever you can however you can has the ability to improve your own life and the life of those around you.
Generosity and compassion are closely linked. Compassion for others and self-compassion can bring about many of the same benefits as generosity. Ebenezer Scrooge learned to be generous through compassion and it improved (and extended, I’m pretty sure) his life AND the lives of those around him.
I wanted the main part of this post to reflect the importance of generosity and the message a Christmas Carol teaches about kindness to others. As an interesting side note though: the three ghosts, past, present, and future take Scrooge on a sort of therapeutic journey.
A basic outline of therapy is to (1) gather background information, ID any issues, and understand how those issues affect you now, (2) process the feelings from the first step, grieve, and reprogram thoughts that are not helpful to you, and (3) take a different view of things, decide to change, and then change.
Do you see how the ghosts took Scrooge through those steps? The Ghost of Christmas Past, helped Scrooge (and the audience) see what led him to be the sort of man he is at the start of the story. The Ghost of Christmas Present helps Scrooge see a different way of doing things and the audience starts to see a small change in Scrooge as he changes some of his thoughts. The Ghost of Christmas Future shows Scrooge how people view his death and how others see him. Ultimately, Scrooge decides to change and takes the steps to bring about that change.
What are some ways you can practice generosity in your own life? Who, in your life, could use more compassion (including yourself)? A new year and winter (as it is in the northern hemisphere) is a great time of year to pause and take a moment to reflect on what you’d like to do differently in your life. Maybe you’d like to increase self-compassion. Or maybe communication skills. Whatever it may be, best wishes to you, may your holidays be gentle.