12/20/2025
Paleo/Vegan and Primal Versions of Frozen Turtle Cheesecake Tarts
I’m sure I’m not alone in wishing someone would start selling a Paleo version of cream cheese. There are several vegan ones available that come close to being Paleo, but all contain at least one forbidden ingredient such as lentils, tofu, xanthan gum, fava beans, etc. So for now, we must create our own substitutes.
I’m working on three different versions of Paleo cream cheese, and finally have one I’m satisfied with. I’ve been tweaking my recipe of Paleo/Vegan cream cheese for a long time and this fall I finally got serious about it. I had tried all the various methods of soaking and processing cashews but never felt my cream cheese was smooth enough.
Recently I tried a quick soak followed by an overnight soak and that did the trick. For the quick soak I poured boiling filtered water over the cashews, covered them and let sit on the counter for 2 hours. After draining and rinsing them, I covered them with filtered water and refrigerated them for about 10 hours. After processing them in my Vitamix blender and tamping them down, I had the thick smooth cream I needed.
The second nondairy cream cheese I’m working on is a cultured cream cheese that does not use lemon juice or apple cider to give it its tang. Instead, I use the powder from probiotic capsules and let it ferment. Because so many people are allergic to tree nuts, the third Paleo cream cheese I’m working on is one that is nut free and vegan, which is the most challenging of the three.
For these Frozen Turtle Cheesecake Tarts (which are also gluten free), I used a pecan and almond flour nut crust. For the Primal tart I used melted butter to bind the ingredients and maple sugar to sweeten. For the Paleo/Vegan one I used melted refined coconut oil and coconut sugar. I’ve made these crusts before but never at the same time so now I could compare them. I preferred the taste of the coconut sugar over maple sugar since its flavor is bolder and reminded me of toffee.
After sampling the Primal tart, my tasters thought I should include more chocolate. For the Paleo tart, I added a layer of dark chocolate ganache on top of the crust.
I always start with making the Primal (Paleo with dairy) version of the tart. Once I am satisfied with this I move on to the Paleo/Vegan one and work to get this as close as possible in taste to the one with dairy cream cheese.
For the Primal caramel sauce, I used cream, butter, powdered maple sugar, and honey which I combined with dairy cream cheese and whipped cream also sweetened with powdered maple sugar for the tart filling. Since honey is not vegan, I used powdered coconut sugar to sweeten both the Paleo caramel sauce and the whipped coconut cream for the filling.
The only drawback to using coconut sugar is the dark color of my filling. For this reason when I made the caramel sauce to drizzle on top, I sweetened it with palm sugar. Otherwise, the caramel sauce would have blended into the chocolate glaze and you wouldn’t even see it.
Palm sugar is made by boiling the sap collected from palm flowers until it is reduced to sugar crystals. It comes in a variety of colors but the one I buy for Thai cooking is golden in color and worked well in my caramel sauce. It has all the sweetness of sugar but with the addition of iron, protein, and potassium. (It’s wonderful in coffee!)
In response to my tasters’ request for more chocolate, I increased the amount of glaze I had used to top the Primal tart. For that tart I had drizzled caramel sauce over the top of each slice and sprinkled each with roasted pecans. But for the Paleo tart I drizzled caramel sauce over the entire tart and sprinkled roasted pecans on top, as well as drizzling a small amount of more caramel sauce over each slice.
Top: Primal (Paleo with Dairy) Frozen Turtle Cheesecake Tart
Bottom: Paleo/Vegan Frozen Turtle Cheesecake Tart