04/12/2026
These is some uproar in the childbirth communities online right now as a hospital system hired doulas to be 24/7 on staff. I offered this response to a major debate amongst providers online-and felt I should publish it here as well.
“As a prior L&D nurse and very experienced doula who also works in and near a hospital that offers in house doula services, I have concerns I would like to share.
1st) -I was a fierce patient advocate as a nurse- and wasn’t afraid to stand up to Doctors who weren’t putting their patients best interests first. However-it was HARD to work in the system and fight against it. Doulas who get paid by the hospital are not truly free to advocate without fear of harming their employment and work environment. In my current work-I may not see the same doctor twice in a year as I cover 9 hospitals and countless doctors, midwives, and nurses. I feel free to say something and truly help my client advocate for themselves because I don’t have to work day to day with and under them like I did as a nurse. Only the strongest, most confident nurses and now doulas will be able to truly stand up for families in reducing obstetrical violence and trauma.
2nd) When a doula meets a family already in the room, where a mom may already be tired, in pain, half dressed and vulnerable, -They are already past the point where true education, advocacy training, and physical/emotional/pain mediation preparation can occur! Half of what doulas bring to the care of pregnant women is chopped out!
Is there value to having some support vs none- Of Course! However- these women are getting a weaker, watered down benefit.
I’ve covered for other doulas in emergency situations-meeting them at the bedside. I give my best to these women in that moment- but I don’t know them-their real desires and hopes-so I can’t truly advocate for them in the same way. And I have not been able to help them prepare like I do my own clients. IT IS NOT THE SAME!
Reasons I left bedside nursing for doula work include:
A) avoiding the turnover at shift end that leaves a family in a vulnerable state mid process. You can’t build deep new bonds of trust at this stage- This physiologically hurts her oxytocin flow and progress. Hospital doula shift work help Doulas live easily scheduled lives, and help hospital PR- not birthing families.
B)Families benefit far more from preparation, education, and trusting relationships built over time and BEFORE labor. - Anyone can show up the day of a marathon and run- but if you have an experienced coach helping you gear up for months before the race-your outcomes will be better! This is especially true for my VBAC clients and first time moms. In the room introductions leave out the chance to make an informed plan, and prepare for your best birth.
C) Nurses are assigned patients- Doula care begins with interviews-and choice. Personalities matter, value sets, and philosophies make a difference in who you want in the most sacred space of your birth! If there’s a doula assigned to you when you show up- you miss out on that crucial piece! Now families show up to a birth and they won’t know which Nurse, OB, or doula who will be there when their baby arrives! Again- this helps the hospital PR, and the providers schedules-but not the families.
D)Labor and birth are not the end of need for reassurance and follow up. The weeks following birth are crucial for these overwhelmed, tired, anxious, emotional new parents as they figure things out. Having a trusted, knowledgeable guide you chose, and who walked through your birth with you coming into the home following up is so important. Even when I have met a mom in hospital as I covered for another doula, I still followed up in home the remaining weeks to help them process and recover. Will these shift working doulas be stepping into that space?
If there is no before labor, no after birth, no trust based relationship built over time, no preparation/educational benefit leading up to birth, no choice in who your doula is, and it’s shift based-so care might swap out mid labor- then these hospitals aren’t employing doulas- they may as well just change the nurse staffing levels to be one on one care-and have them do a weekend training on positioning and pain mediation techniques.
And by offering this at the hospital and calling it by the same name- many women won’t know the difference. Accidentally settling for this shadow version of what true doula work does offer.
The proven benefits will decrease because half the work is skipped.
Instead- more insurances should be-(and are) covering care of doulas OUTSIDE of institutions Medicaid coverage should be universal (though we are improving in number and coverage!-currently 26 states and Washington DC do cover doula services-outside of this institutionalized model)
I would say 90% of my clients are insurance pay-many young military families (as I’m also a military spouse and take their insurance because they need this support so much). My kind of wholistic care isn’t just for the elite private pay-it’s for everyone. This is where care needs to go-we don’t need to water it down and institutionalize it to make it more available.”