09/12/2017
A whole passel of studies came out today in NEJM about immunotherapy in melanoma in connection with a European oncology meeting. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1709684 =article
This is still a developing story but where we are right now is that after surgery for a Stage III melanoma, nivolumab (Opdivo) is better than Ipilimumab (Yervoy). Stage III melanoma is an invasive melanoma that has spread to lymph nodes, usually identified in the context of a lymph node dissection in the region of the original tumor. Today's publication is the CheckMate 238 study. After 3 years, 70% of patients treated with postop Opdivo were alive and disease free, more than the patients treated with postop Yervoy. I should point out that as of today, only Yervoy is FDA approved for treatment after surgery.
We do have an older immunotherapy approved for melanoma after surgery in Stage III, pegylated Interferon alfa, product known as Sylatron. Sylatron has not been compared head to head versus opdivo or yervoy, but numbers have been reported in that medication also and it's useful to try to draw inferences from the literature.
Probably opdivo is better than sylatron. At three years on sylatron, about 50% of patients had not relapsed, not quite as good as opdivo's 70%. Different patient populations, true, but that's a pretty big numerical difference. Opdivo isn't FDA approved yet in this setting but sylatron is.
Sylatron is probably not worse than yervoy. Yervoy offered a 60% freedom from relapse at 3 years compared to sylatron's 50%. Again, different patient populations, so take it for what it's worth. Yervoy is also pretty toxic, most patients had to stop the protocol partway through. The FDA did approve it but most people will get a disabling diarrhea and some of those cases require hospital admission.
Sylatron is no picnic either but it had about a 70% rate of patients continuing on the plan.
Opdivo is not nearly as toxic, only about 9% of patients had to stop taking it because of side effects.
Taking all these facts together, we probably have enough information to ask the FDA for approval of opdivo in the postop setting, and it probably works the best out of the different medications studied in this setting. I wouldn't be surprised if we didn't see an FDA approval soon.
I would be happy to see Yervoy in the adjuvant setting go away. It carries a ton of toxicity and you have to give it at a whopping dose of 10mg/kg which translates to $100k per infusion, $400k total cost for the initial four infusions and you're supposed to continue it every three months for up to three years. I suspect this was a case of "our efficacy at the regular 3mg/kg dose wasn't very good, so let's see if a huge higher dose will give us the response we're looking for."
On another related note, "combination" therapy with Opdivo AND Yervoy in the metastatic melanoma setting electrified the community only about two years ago and garnered an FDA approval. Today we also saw in NEJM updated results from this study, the Checkmate 067 study. The executive summary is that Yervoy doesn't seem to add much, unless you're BRAF positive, which is only a minority of these cases. If the BRAF is positive, you also have another option in the BRAF oral inhibitors such as Zelboraf or Mekinist and Tafinlar combo. The combination therapy therefore also probably goes away. Look for yervoy, so promising only two years ago, to become at most a niche player.
And another related note we now have a trial of the all-oral Mekinist and Tafinlar combo in the postop BRAF-positive melanoma setting, producing also about a 60% chance of being alive and disease free at three years, comparable to sylatron and yervoy but perhaps a little less good than opdivo. 26% of patients had to stop treatment due to side effects, about the same as sylatron.
Debates will rage on (at least in oncology circles) whether oral combo therapy or IV immunotherapy will be more useful to us clinicians. We know more than we did yesterday but there is still a lot to learn tomorrow.
Original Article from The New England Journal of Medicine — Overall Survival with Combined Nivolumab and Ipilimumab in Advanced Melanoma