30/04/2026
Book Report | Melanie Klein’s Envy and Gratitude is a seminal work on envy and both Carlos Byington, and Ann and Barry Ulanov make reference to her thinking.
The child has urgent desires for food as well as near constant affirmations of love and security. The mother is envied for her ability to dispense gratification. Klein discusses many aspects of idealisation, of depression, of defences employed to counter anxiety, of positive and negative developments that may or may not build the child’s ego. She also illustrates with case studies.
In a compact book on creative envy Carlos Byington sees covetousness as a structuring function encouraging growth and human development. The play Amadeus vaunts the creative genius of Mozart, contrasting the equally powerful bitter stagnation and self-destructive behaviour resulting from Salieri’s defences against his own creativity. For Byington there is a strong influence of Christian morality whose binary division of life=Good death=Bad includes concepts of envy and jealousy as sinful and tending to be repressed into the shadow.
The Ulanovs have taken apart the fairy story of Cinderella to show envy in many aspects: that of the envied; those who envy; the three mother figures of the good-but-late mother, the cruel stepmother and the fairy godmother; envy of the masculine (including Cinderella’s animus, while the prince is the only male figure in the story), and envy of goodness. The second half of the book opens to the morals being taught. Where envy is sin, the envier faces spiritual loss and degradation. Extreme envy acts on the three sisters to dry up their desire for relating to the male s*x. Cinderella’s values such as patience, diligence and care are characteristics that oil a well-functioning society.
To slightly stretch a point on projection of envy, Robert Johnson’s book Inner Gold speaks to the need for us to find another person who holds a quality or qualities which we admire or envy, not realising that we already contain it. Perhaps we’re not ready to see it in ourselves; we see it in another and envy it. Eventually, we‘re able to recognise it in ourselves and we take back our gold.
~ Book Report written by Debra West, Librarian, Jean Albert Library, CG Jung Centre
Bibliography:
Klein, Melanie (1975) Envy and Gratitude & other works 1946-1963. New York: Delta.
Byington, Carlos Madeu Botelho (2003) Creative Envy: The Rescue of One of Civilization’s Major Forces. Wilmett, ILL: Chiron.
Ulanov, Ann & Barry Ulanov Cinderella and Her Sisters: The Envied and the Envying. Philadelphia: Westminster Press.
Johnson, Robert (2008) Inner Gold: Understanding Psychological Projection. Kihei, Hawai’i:Koa Books.
Jean Albert Library - Visitors are Welcome
The Jean Albert Library at the C.G. Jung Centre has an impressive collection of books on a wide variety of Jungian topics. It’s open on Tuesdays 10am – 2pm, and on Thursdays from 2pm - 7pm. Becoming a member allows one to borrow books and audio-visual materials. Explore at https://jungsouthernafrica.co.za/jean-albert-library/