27/07/2020
A LESSON IN HOW TO GRAPPLE WITH CONTRADICTIONS: MY MOMENTS WITH NTATE ERIC KHOTSENG, BY VELI MBELE, 23 JULY 2020
"To criticise the people's shortcomings is necessary, . . . but in doing so we must truly take the stand of the people and speak out of whole-hearted eagerness to protect and educate them. To treat comrades like enemies is to go over to the stand of the enemy." -Mao Tse Tung
Talks at the Yenan Forum on Literature and Art" (May 1942), Selected Works, Vol. III, p. 92.
Dear Ntate Khotseng,
From one political activist to the other, I have chosen to anchor my reflections on my interaction with you on Mao Tse Tung's philosophical musings on the nature and character of what is called contradictions.
We are still digesting the news of your unexpected passing.Your departure comes at a time when we are experiencing an unprecedented number of deaths of Black people, who are close to us or servants of the Black Race.
The phenomenon of the Corona virus not withstanding, I am not sure if there is a much deeper explanation for what seems to be an era of accelerated and pervasive death, for us as Black people in South AfriKKKa.
In trying to make sense of this existential conundrum, I recently opined "As Black people, death has always been our pillow.It has been our blanket.It is the very bed we go to sleep in every night.Death is the very roof over heads.The very air we breathe".
Your death, has now just added to the weight of the mental labour that I have dedicated to this existential conundrum.I am sure you would have offered an incisive critique of my musings in this respect.
This is one of the attributes that attracted me to you: the precision with which you were able to split cognitive atoms.I wish to dedicate much of this reflection to the story behind the image that I have chosen to accompany this tribute.
As you may remember, this picture was taken at some restuarant on the Saturday of the 7 November, 2015, at the Diamond Pavilion mall, in Ga-Kgosi Galeshewe.
This was the day I met you for the first time off social media. Prior to our meeting, you and I had already crossed swords (cerebrally speaking), on a number of occasions on Facebook.
It was also on the same day that I met (for the first time) another Facebook friend of mine and Sister Nomonde Seeco (also at the Diamond Pavilion mall).Under the current circumstances, the context and character of our meeting is particularly important to me.
As stated, after numerous exchanges on Facebook, we agreed there may be greater value in us dedicating time to having a face-to-face interaction, off social media (an approach that experience has taught me always achieves much better results).
We then agreed that, when next I am in Ga-Kgosi Galeshewe, I will give you advanced notice so we can keep our promise to each other.As our Ancestors would have it, our first meeting happened on Saturday 7 November, 2015.
Me being me, I arrived much earlier than the appointed 12:00 pm and had already indicated to the Sister who was serving me that I was expecting someone to join me.
At about 11: 47 am, you walked in, flashing a smile and moving your arms almost boisterously.We exchanged a warm embrace and enquired on one another's well being.
We talked for over two hours and punctuated our conversation with drinks (non alcoholic for the record).Our conversation was relaxed in its temperament, but very comprehensive in its scope.
We spoke about our personal projects, our political activism and the state of our political movements (I was formally part of AZAPO at the time).
Unsurprisingly, we also reflected on the direction things were taking in South AfriKKKa and where we as a people are likely to be in a few years time.We also spoke about our shared passion for reading and reflective writing.
In that one moment that I spent with you, I got to learn a number things about and from you.One was that your sometimes ruthless mind was not necessarily a reflection of the essence of your personality.
That you had an incredible appreciation for incisive thought, reflection and literature.I could also gather that you sometimes were not as patient with people who may not grasp things at the same level that you were grasping them (this of course didn't make you an aberration).
I left our meeting with all sorts of additional positive impressions of you.Enhanced in my knowledge of you.One of them was that, you are an extremely gifted thinker and that you would be of much value in an institute for strategic reflection.
My own experience is that, in contemporary Afrika, Black political parties are not the ideal vessels for independent and critical Black political or philosophical thought.They are simply antithetical to this.
Your sudden departure doesn't just constitute an incalculable loss, but it is also monumentally tragic that we should lose someone of your calibre, at a time when critical and independent thought is increasingly being criminalised, by those who derive fraudulent financial and other forms of benefit, from the status quo.
I am grateful to my Ancestors and yours for making it possible for our paths to cross.I consider myself privileged to have had the honour of sitting down with you (away from the pretense and insincerity of social media exchanges).
The privilege to get into the soul of your mind.The privilege to hear your voice and not just read your words.The privilege to hear you laugh and understand that behind your often scathing political treatises-is just a Black man like me, nothing more, nothing less.
The privilege that someone far older than me would see value in taking time off their schedule just so they could sit and talk to me.I really appreciate the respect Grootman.
In my view, one of the most enduring lessons that your life taught is how we must handle the contractions between ourselves and others.This is a complex and permanent struggle in our relations with others.
Being a man of text like me, I suspect you would appreciate it if I conclude in the same manner that I opened, by once again leaning on the wisdom of Chairman Mao.
In his seminal essay titled 'On Contradiction' (August 1937),Selected Works, Vol.I, p. 344, he writes:
Contradiction and struggle are universal and absolute, but the methods of resolving contradictions, that is, the forms of struggle, differ according to the differences in the nature of the contradictions. Some contradictions are characterized by open antagonism and others are not. In accordance with the concrete development of things, some contradictions, which were originally non-antagonistic, develop into antagonistic ones, while others which were originally antagonistic develop into non-antagonistic ones.
My heartfelt condolences go to your family, friends, comrades and movement, the African National Congress. Thank you for all the lessons.Ours was but a brief moment but one that lingers nevertheless.Go well Son of The Land! Go well!
Camagu❤🖤💚
Veli Mbele is an Afrocentric essayist, political historian and secretary of the Black Power Front