09/04/2025
Is Waterbirth Really Safe?
Let’s Break Down the Physiology, Science & Misconceptions
Waterbirth is often celebrated for its calm and soothing environment and it can be a beautiful and safe option. But real safety comes from knowing how the body works, how babies transition to breathing, and understanding where common myths and real risks meet.
Common Misconceptions About Waterbirth:
- “Babies don’t breathe underwater.”
Babies are not supposed to breathe underwater...but they can if their protective reflexes are overridden (e.g. by stress or lack of oxygen).
- “The airway stays closed until air hits the face.”
This is not how the physiology works. Babies don’t have a "valve" that seals the airway. They rely on reflexes (like the mammalian dive reflex) to delay breathing, but it’s not a guaranteed seal.
- “They only take their first breath when the top of their head touches air.”
Many people believe that birth = breath, but the first breath is triggered by multiple factors: sudden temperature drop, exposure to air, sensory input (like light and touch), and the loss of placental oxygen supply. If some of these cues happen while the baby is still submerged, they may try to breathe underwater, especially if stressed.
How Babies "Breathe" in the Womb vs. at Birth
In the womb:
- Babies do not breathe air
- Oxygen is delivered through the placenta via the umbilical cord
- The lungs are filled with amniotic fluid and stay non-functional for gas exchange
- The diaphragm and chest do make practice breathing motions, but these are more for development, not actual breathing
At birth:
- Once the baby is born, the placenta detaches, and oxygen through the cord begins to drop
- This triggers a cascade of reflexes:
- The surfactant (a substance in the lungs) allows alveoli to open
- The lungs absorb amniotic fluid and prepare to expand
- The first breath is triggered by the sudden temperature change, gravity, light, touch, and pressure change
- The foramen ovale and ductus arteriosus (two fetal heart structures) begin to close, transitioning circulation from fetal to newborn
In a waterbirth:
- If all goes smoothly, the baby is lifted from the water before reflexes are triggered and begins to breathe upon exposure to air
- However, if there's fetal distress, a delay in lifting, or the head is partially exposed, the baby may try to breathe before it’s safe—leading to water aspiration
Why Babies Might Breathe in Waterbirth (and What Increases Risk)
- Fetal stress (e.g. cord compression, meconium) can cause gasping reflex even underwater
- Hypoxia (low oxygen) triggers early breath attempts as the brain tries to survive
- Head delivered but body delayed → baby may be exposed to air + light + touch before being fully born, confusing reflexes
- Water too cold or too hot can disrupt the protective dive reflex
- Improper timing or technique → baby lingers underwater or isn’t brought up quickly
- Lack of skilled provider → Delayed response or irrational response
Tips for a Safer Waterbirth (with Physiology in Mind):
1. Work with an experienced provider
Ensure your team is well trained in waterbirth safety
2. Keep water temp between 95–100°F (35–37.5°C)
This mimics the womb environment and prevents thermal shock that could trigger premature breath attempts
3. Avoid prolonged head-out/body-in situations
The baby should be born and brought to the surface in one continuous motion, if the head is born first for an extended time before the body, the mother may want to consider bringing the baby out of the submerged water.
4. Don’t let baby linger underwater
Once the baby is out, don’t wait, bring them up to initiate normal breathing safely
5. Monitor for signs of distress
Fetal heart tones, cord issues, or prolonged pushing should prompt reevaluation of waterbirth
6. Avoid allowing the baby to briefly hit the air before submerging again; this can confuse their natural reflexes and increase the risk of inhalation | If a mother rises out of the water as the baby crowns and the baby’s face touches the air, they may instinctively take in oxygen. If the mother then sits back in the water or if the baby drops underwater after birth, this can confuse the baby’s reflexes and increase the risk of inhalation
Honest Cons to Consider:
- Labor may slow in water due to buoyancy, over-relaxation or poor positioning
- Some feel less aware of pushing urges
- Water can obstruct provider visibility during crowning
- Emergency maneuvers can be delayed compared to land births
- The fear of aspiration may create panic or rush decision-making
- A rare but real risk of water aspiration exists if reflexes are overridden or birth is mismanaged
What Does the Science Say?
Studies show that planned, low-risk waterbirths with trained providers have good outcomes. But:
- Aspiration has occurred in documented cases, especially when babies are kept underwater too long or born in distress
- Placental oxygenation can drop quickly once the cord is compressed or the placenta separates, making timely emergence crucial
- The diving reflex is protective but not perfect, it should not be the sole safeguard
Bottom Line:
Waterbirth can be beautiful, but safety depends on how well the physiology is respected
Choose waterbirth if you're low-risk:
Avoid it if baby shows distress, birth is prolonged in fully submerged water or you intuitvely do not feel it is the right choice for you.
Know Gods design. Trust your body. Make informed decisions.
📸•
Faith Driven Childbirth (Assisted/Unassisted)
